Frankel Allan S, Leonard Michael W, Denham Charles R
Partners Healthcare, 115 4th Avenue, Needham, MA 02494, USA.
Health Serv Res. 2006 Aug;41(4 Pt 2):1690-709. doi: 10.1111/j.1475-6773.2006.00572.x.
Disparate health care provider attitudes about autonomy, teamwork, and administrative operations have added to the complexity of health care delivery and are a central factor in medicine's unacceptably high rate of errors. Other industries have improved their reliability by applying innovative concepts to interpersonal relationships and administrative hierarchical structures (Chandler 1962). In the last 10 years the science of patient safety has become more sophisticated, with practical concepts identified and tested to improve the safety and reliability of care.
Three initiatives stand out as worthy regarding interpersonal relationships and the application of provider concerns to shape operational change: The development and implementation of Fair and Just Culture principles, the broad use of Teamwork Training and Communication, and tools like WalkRounds that promote the alignment of leadership and frontline provider perspectives through effective use of adverse event data and provider comments.
Fair and Just Culture, Teamwork Training, and WalkRounds are described, and implementation examples provided. The argument is made that they must be systematically and consistently implemented in an integrated fashion.
There are excellent examples of institutions applying Just Culture principles, Teamwork Training, and Leadership WalkRounds--but to date, they have not been comprehensively instituted in health care organizations in a cohesive and interdependent manner. To achieve reliability, organizations need to begin thinking about the relationship between these efforts and linking them conceptually.
医疗服务提供者在自主权、团队合作及行政运作方面存在不同态度,这增加了医疗服务的复杂性,也是医疗行业错误率高得令人无法接受的一个核心因素。其他行业通过将创新理念应用于人际关系和行政层级结构提高了可靠性(钱德勒,1962年)。在过去十年里,患者安全科学变得更加成熟,已确定并测试了一些实用理念以提高医疗服务的安全性和可靠性。
在人际关系以及将医疗服务提供者的关切应用于推动运营变革方面,有三项举措值得关注:公平公正文化原则的制定与实施、团队合作培训与沟通的广泛应用,以及像巡视这样的工具,通过有效利用不良事件数据和医疗服务提供者的意见,促进领导层与一线医疗服务提供者观点的一致。
对公平公正文化、团队合作培训和巡视进行了描述,并提供了实施案例。文章认为必须以综合方式系统且持续地实施这些举措。
有一些机构应用公正文化原则、团队合作培训和领导层巡视的出色范例,但迄今为止,它们尚未在医疗保健组织中以连贯且相互依存的方式全面推行。为实现可靠性,各组织需要开始思考这些努力之间的关系并在概念上加以联系。