Ploeg Jenny, Feightner John, Hutchison Brian, Patterson Christopher, Sigouin Christopher, Gauld Mary
School of Nursing, McMaster University, Hamilton, Ont.
Can Fam Physician. 2005 Sep;51(9):1244-5.
To determine the effectiveness of preventive primary care outreach interventions aimed at older people. Knowing whether such interventions are effective could help busy family physicians make choices about which preventive care services to provide.
We searched MEDLINE, CINAHL, AgeLine, Cochrane Controlled Trials Register, and EMBASE databases and reviewed the reference lists of retrieved articles.
We included studies of preventive primary care interventions aimed at patients 65 years and older if the studies were randomized controlled trials and if any of the following outcomes was reported: mortality, living in the community, admission to acute care hospitals, and admission to long-term care. We defined preventive primary care outreach as proactive, provider-initiated care, which can be provided by nurses, physicians, other professionals, or volunteers, that is in addition to usual care and is provided in primary care settings. Such care can be provided through home visits, office visits, telephone contacts, or a combination of these methods.
We assessed the quality of studies and extracted descriptive information on study populations, interventions, and outcomes for 19 trials involving 14,911 patients. Summary odds ratios were estimated for each outcome using a random effects model.
This review showed that studies of preventive primary care outreach interventions aimed at older people were associated with a 17% reduction of mortality and a 23% increased likelihood of continuing to live in the community.
确定针对老年人的预防性初级保健外展干预措施的有效性。了解此类干预措施是否有效有助于忙碌的家庭医生选择提供哪些预防性保健服务。
我们检索了MEDLINE、CINAHL、AgeLine、Cochrane对照试验注册库和EMBASE数据库,并查阅了检索文章的参考文献列表。
如果研究为随机对照试验,且报告了以下任何一项结果:死亡率、社区生活情况、入住急症医院情况和入住长期护理机构情况,我们纳入针对65岁及以上患者的预防性初级保健干预研究。我们将预防性初级保健外展定义为主动的、由提供者发起的护理,可由护士、医生、其他专业人员或志愿者提供,是常规护理之外且在初级保健机构提供的护理。此类护理可通过家访、门诊、电话联系或这些方法的组合来提供。
我们评估了研究质量,并提取了19项涉及14911名患者的试验的研究人群、干预措施和结果的描述性信息。使用随机效应模型估计每个结果的汇总比值比。
本综述表明,针对老年人的预防性初级保健外展干预研究与死亡率降低17%以及继续在社区生活的可能性增加23%相关。