Segal Steven P, Burgess Philip
Mental Health and Social Welfare Research Group, School of Social Welfare, 120 Haviland Hall MC 7400, Berkeley, CA 94720-7400, USA.
Soc Work Health Care. 2006;43(2-3):37-51. doi: 10.1300/J010v43n02_04.
This study considers four hypotheses regarding the impact of extended involuntary outpatient commitment orders on services utilization.
All Victorian Psychiatric Case Register (VPCR) patients who had extended (180+ day) outpatient commitment orders in the nine year study period and a matched treatment compliant comparison group with extended periods of outpatient care (N = 1182), both with at least two years of post-episode experience, were evaluated. Pre/post episode utilization was compared via paired t tests with individuals as their own controls. Logistic and OLS regression as well as repeated measures ANOVA via the GLM SPSS program and post hoc t tests were used to evaluate between group and across time differences.
Extended episodes of care for both groups were associated with reduced use of hospitalization and increases in outpatient services. Extended orders did not promote voluntary participation in the post-period. Outpatient services during the extended episode for those on orders were raised to the level experienced by the treatment compliant comparison group and maintained at that level via subsequent renewal of orders throughout the patients' careers. OLS regression results indicate that approximately six community care service days were required for those on orders to achieve a one-day reduction in hospital utilization following the extended episode.
Outpatient commitment for those on extended orders in the Victorian context enables a level of community-based services provision, unexpected in the absence of this delivery system, which provides an alternative to hospitalization.
本研究考量了四条关于延长非自愿门诊治疗令对服务利用影响的假设。
对在九年研究期内拥有延长(180天以上)门诊治疗令的所有维多利亚州精神病病例登记册(VPCR)患者,以及一个与之匹配的接受长期门诊治疗的依从治疗对照组(N = 1182)进行评估,两组患者均有至少两年的发作后经历。通过配对t检验将发作前后的利用率进行比较,以个体自身作为对照。使用逻辑回归和普通最小二乘法回归,以及通过GLM SPSS程序进行重复测量方差分析和事后t检验来评估组间差异和跨时间差异。
两组延长的治疗期均与住院使用率降低和门诊服务增加相关。延长令并未促进后期的自愿参与。接受命令者在延长治疗期的门诊服务提升至依从治疗对照组所经历的水平,并在患者整个病程中通过后续命令续签维持在该水平。普通最小二乘法回归结果表明,接受命令者在延长治疗期后,大约需要六个社区护理服务日才能使住院使用率降低一天。
在维多利亚州的背景下,对接受延长命令者进行门诊治疗能够提供一定水平的社区服务,而在没有这种服务提供系统的情况下这是出乎意料的,它为住院治疗提供了一种替代方案。