Koo John, Blum Robin R, Lebwohl Mark
UCSF Psoriasis and Phototherapy Treatment Center, Department of Dermatology, University of California, San Francisco 94118, USA.
J Am Acad Dermatol. 2006 Oct;55(4):637-41. doi: 10.1016/j.jaad.2006.05.026.
The merit of topical sequential therapy involving clobetasol foam and calcipotriene ointment has not been experimentally demonstrated.
We sought to assess the short-term efficacy of twice-daily clobetasol foam plus calcipotriene ointment compared with either agent alone as monotherapy and to compare long-term use of weekday calcipotriene ointment with or without clobetasol foam weekend pulse therapy.
Eighty-six subjects with plaque-type psoriasis received twice-daily treatment with clobetasol foam plus calcipotriene ointment or either agent as monotherapy for 2 weeks. Subjects in the combination group who achieved remission received weekday calcipotriene plus weekend pulse therapy with either clobetasol foam or vehicle for 6 months.
After 2 weeks, psoriasis scores were significantly lower (P < .001) in the combination therapy group (adjusted trunk lesion score = 0.67) compared with monotherapy with either agent (lesion scores = 1.40 calcipotriene, 1.13 clobetasol foam). During the follow-up "weekday-weekend" phase, after 6 months, weekend pulse clobetasol foam was associated with a trend toward greater maintenance of remission compared with vehicle (92% improvement of trunk lesion vs 62%).
Small sample size may have hampered the detection of statistical significance during long-term therapy.
The combination of clobetasol foam and calcipotriene ointment is significantly more effective than monotherapy for short-term treatment. Weekday calcipotriene plus weekend pulse clobetasol foam shows a consistent trend toward greater maintenance of remission.
外用氯倍他索泡沫和卡泊三醇软膏序贯疗法的优势尚未得到实验证实。
我们试图评估每日两次使用氯倍他索泡沫加卡泊三醇软膏与单独使用任一药物作为单一疗法的短期疗效,并比较在工作日使用卡泊三醇软膏、周末使用或不使用氯倍他索泡沫脉冲疗法的长期疗效。
86例斑块型银屑病患者接受每日两次氯倍他索泡沫加卡泊三醇软膏治疗或单独使用任一药物作为单一疗法,为期2周。联合治疗组中达到缓解的患者在工作日接受卡泊三醇治疗,周末接受氯倍他索泡沫或赋形剂脉冲治疗,为期6个月。
2周后,联合治疗组的银屑病评分(调整后的躯干皮损评分=0.67)显著低于单独使用任一药物的单一疗法组(皮损评分:卡泊三醇为1.40,氯倍他索泡沫为1.13)(P<0.001)。在随访的“工作日-周末”阶段,6个月后,与赋形剂相比,周末脉冲使用氯倍他索泡沫有维持缓解效果更好的趋势(躯干皮损改善率为92%对62%)。
样本量较小可能妨碍了长期治疗期间统计学显著性的检测。
氯倍他索泡沫和卡泊三醇软膏联合使用在短期治疗中比单一疗法显著更有效。工作日使用卡泊三醇加周末脉冲使用氯倍他索泡沫显示出维持缓解效果更好的一致趋势。