Tickner Joel, Coffin Melissa
Department of Community Health and Sustainability, University of Massachusetts Lowell, Lowell, MA, USA.
J Evid Based Dent Pract. 2006 Mar;6(1):6-15. doi: 10.1016/j.jebdp.2005.12.006.
The precautionary principle calls for preventive actions in the face of uncertain information about risks. It serves as a compass to better guide more health-protective decisions in the face of complex risks. Applying precaution requires thinking more broadly about risks, taking an interdisciplinary approach to science and policy, and considering a wide range of alternatives to potentially harmful activities. While often criticized as antiscientific, the precautionary principle represents a challenge to scientists and public health professionals to develop newer and more effective tools for characterizing and preventing complex risks, in addition to being more explicit about uncertainties. This article examines the role and application of precaution in the context of dental practice, where activities that may convey risks also have public health benefits, and risk trade offs are a possibility. We conclude that the precautionary principle is not at odds with, but rather complements evidence-based practice in situations of scientific uncertainty and complex risks.
预防原则要求在面对关于风险的不确定信息时采取预防行动。它就像一个指南针,在面对复杂风险时更好地指导做出更多保护健康的决策。应用预防措施需要更广泛地思考风险,采取跨学科的科学与政策方法,并考虑针对潜在有害活动的多种替代方案。虽然预防原则常被批评为反科学,但它对科学家和公共卫生专业人员构成了挑战,要求他们开发更新、更有效的工具来描述和预防复杂风险,同时更明确地说明不确定性。本文探讨了预防原则在牙科实践中的作用和应用,在牙科实践中,可能带来风险的活动也具有公共卫生益处,并且存在风险权衡的可能性。我们得出结论,在科学不确定性和复杂风险的情况下,预防原则与循证实践并不矛盾,而是相辅相成。