Shusterman Dennis
Occupational and Environmental Medicine Program, University of Washington, Seattle, Washington, USA.
Clin Allergy Immunol. 2007;19:249-66.
The upper airway occupies a sentinel position with respect to the physical and chemical qualities of the inspired atmosphere. Responses of the upper airway can be acute or chronic, as well as primary (sensory) or secondary (physiologic). Olfaction and sensory irritation are cofactors in the perception of air quality. Secondary reflex responses to airborne irritants may include blockage (airflow obstruction), secretion (with or without associated inflammation), and alterations in mucociliary clearance. Of the above end points, obstruction has been documented in response to a variety of agents, including acetic acid vapor, ammonia, Cl2, ETS, mixed VOCs, vapors from carbonless copy paper, and (variably) SO2. Alterations in mucociliary clearance have been variably observed with SO2 and ETS exposure. A neutrophilic inflammatory response has been documented after acute exposure to either ozone or VOCs, and metaplastic mucosal changes after prolonged exposures to photochemical mixed air pollutants. Augmented reactivity to irritants is a phenotypic characteristic of both nonallergic and allergic rhinitis; however, understanding of underlying mechanisms remains elusive (75-78). Differential physiologic responsiveness to environmental irritant stimuli has been documented by allergic rhinitis status for acetic acid and Cl2 (objectively) and for mixed VOCs (subjectively only). Differential responsiveness by nonallergic rhinitis status has, to our knowledge, been documented for paper dust only, although a somewhat wider array of pollutants (including ETS and carbonless copy paper) has been studied in groups differing by self-reported pollutant reactivity. Interestingly, although the congestive response to allergens and irritants is similar, the underlying mechanisms appear to differ, with neither mast cell degranulation nor cholinergic parasympathetic reflexes appearing critical to the response (Fig. 3). Although neuropeptide release does not accompany Cl2-induced nasal obstruction, in one model system (hypertonic saline challenge), substance P release accompanied augmented secretions (80,81). In yet another hypertonic model (dry mannitol powder challenge), arachidonic acid metabolites characteristic of epithelial cell activation accompanied nasal obstruction (82). The relevance of these model systems to environmentally realistic (airborne) irritants remains unclear at this time. Overall, nonallergic rhinitis has received considerably less attention than has allergic rhinitis in the context of descriptive, pathophysiologic, and intervention studies. This statement applies equally in the context of environmental nonallergic rhinitis. As is hopefully evident from the above discussion, many potential research questions in this area remain to be addressed.
上呼吸道在吸入空气的物理和化学性质方面处于关键位置。上呼吸道的反应可以是急性或慢性的,也可以是原发性(感觉性)或继发性(生理性)的。嗅觉和感觉刺激是空气质量感知中的辅助因素。对空气中刺激物的继发性反射反应可能包括阻塞(气流受阻)、分泌(伴有或不伴有相关炎症)以及黏液纤毛清除功能的改变。在上述终点中,已证实多种物质可引发阻塞反应,包括醋酸蒸汽、氨、氯气、环境烟草烟雾、混合挥发性有机化合物、无碳复写纸的蒸汽以及(在不同程度上)二氧化硫。二氧化硫和环境烟草烟雾暴露后,黏液纤毛清除功能的改变情况各不相同。急性暴露于臭氧或挥发性有机化合物后,已证实会出现中性粒细胞炎症反应,长期暴露于光化学混合空气污染物后会出现化生黏膜变化。对刺激物的反应性增强是变应性和非变应性鼻炎的一个表型特征;然而,对其潜在机制的理解仍然难以捉摸(75 - 78)。变应性鼻炎状态下,已证实对醋酸和氯气(客观上)以及混合挥发性有机化合物(仅主观上)对环境刺激物的生理反应存在差异。据我们所知,仅针对纸尘记录了非变应性鼻炎状态下的反应差异,尽管在根据自我报告的污染物反应性分组的研究中,对更广泛的一系列污染物(包括环境烟草烟雾和无碳复写纸)进行了研究。有趣的是,尽管变应性鼻炎和非变应性鼻炎对变应原和刺激物的充血反应相似,但其潜在机制似乎不同,肥大细胞脱颗粒和胆碱能副交感神经反射对该反应似乎都不重要(图3)。尽管氯气诱导的鼻塞不伴有神经肽释放,但在一个模型系统(高渗盐水激发)中,P物质释放伴随着分泌物增加(80,81)。在另一个高渗模型(干甘露醇粉激发)中,上皮细胞活化特有的花生四烯酸代谢产物伴随着鼻塞(82)。目前尚不清楚这些模型系统与环境现实(空气中的)刺激物的相关性。总体而言,在描述性、病理生理学和干预性研究方面,非变应性鼻炎受到的关注远少于变应性鼻炎。这一说法在环境性非变应性鼻炎的背景下同样适用。从上述讨论中有望明显看出,该领域许多潜在的研究问题仍有待解决。