Wieringa Frank T, Berger Jacques, Dijkhuizen Marjoleine A, Hidayat Adi, Ninh Nguyen X, Utomo Budi, Wasantwisut Emorn, Winichagoon Pattanee
Department of Internal Medicine, UMCN, Radboud University, Nijmegen, The Netherlands.
J Nutr. 2007 Feb;137(2):466-71. doi: 10.1093/jn/137.2.466.
Deficiencies of iron and zinc are prevalent worldwide. Interactions between these micronutrients therefore have important consequences, also for supplementation. To investigate effects on hemoglobin and zinc concentrations and interactions of iron and zinc supplementation in infants, data from 4 parallel, randomized, placebo-controlled, double-blind trials in Indonesia, Thailand, and Vietnam were pooled. Infants (n=2468), aged 4-6 mo, were supplemented daily with iron (10 mg) and/or zinc (10 mg) for 6 mo. At 3 sites, infants were given vitamin A capsules (VAC) at recruitment. Combined supplementation reduced prevalences of anemia by 21% (P<0.01) and zinc deficiency by 10% (P<0.05) but was less effective (P<0.05) than supplementation with either iron (28% reduction in anemia) or zinc alone (18% reduction in zinc deficiency). Iron reduced the effect of zinc supplementation (interaction P<0.01), but had no separate effect on zinc status, whereas zinc supplementation had a negative effect on hemoglobin concentrations (-2.5 g/L, P<0.001), independent of iron supplementation (Pinteraction=0.25). The effect of iron supplementation on hemoglobin concentrations was almost twice as large in boys than in girls (effect size 12.0 vs. 6.8 g/L, respectively). In infants not receiving iron, VAC administration tended to be associated with lower (3.2%, P=0.07) hemoglobin concentrations. Combined supplementation of iron and zinc was safe and effective in reducing the high prevalences of anemia and iron and zinc deficiencies. Zinc supplementation may negatively affect iron status but iron supplementation does not seem to affect zinc status. Furthermore, VAC administration in the absence of iron supplementation may increase the incidence of anemia.
铁和锌缺乏在全球范围内普遍存在。因此,这些微量营养素之间的相互作用具有重要影响,对补充剂而言亦是如此。为了研究铁和锌补充剂对婴儿血红蛋白和锌浓度的影响以及它们之间的相互作用,我们汇总了印度尼西亚、泰国和越南进行的4项平行、随机、安慰剂对照、双盲试验的数据。年龄在4至6个月的婴儿(n = 2468)每天补充铁(10毫克)和/或锌(10毫克),为期6个月。在3个试验点,婴儿在招募时服用维生素A胶囊(VAC)。联合补充剂使贫血患病率降低了21%(P<0.01),锌缺乏患病率降低了10%(P<0.05),但效果不如单独补充铁(贫血患病率降低28%)或锌(锌缺乏患病率降低18%)(P<0.05)。铁降低了锌补充剂的效果(交互作用P<0.01),但对锌状态没有单独影响,而锌补充剂对血红蛋白浓度有负面影响(-2.5克/升,P<0.001),与铁补充剂无关(交互作用P = 0.25)。铁补充剂对血红蛋白浓度的影响在男孩中几乎是女孩的两倍(效应量分别为12.0克/升和6.8克/升)。在未接受铁补充剂的婴儿中,服用VAC往往与较低的血红蛋白浓度相关(3.2%,P = 0.07)。铁和锌联合补充在降低贫血以及铁和锌缺乏的高患病率方面是安全有效的。锌补充剂可能会对铁状态产生负面影响,但铁补充剂似乎不会影响锌状态。此外,在未补充铁的情况下服用VAC可能会增加贫血的发生率。