Orsel K, Dekker A, Bouma A, Stegeman J A, de Jong M C M
Faculty of Veterinary Medicine, Department of Farm Animal Health, Utrecht University, The Netherlands.
Vaccine. 2007 Mar 30;25(14):2673-9. doi: 10.1016/j.vaccine.2006.11.048. Epub 2006 Dec 6.
Sheep are well known to be susceptible for foot and mouth disease virus (FMDV), but it is unknown whether the infection can spread and persist in a sheep population. We therefore quantified virus transmission by performing experiments with FMD virus strain O/NET/2001 in groups of lambs. We used six groups of four lambs each, in which half of each group was inoculated and the other half was contact-exposed. To quantify the effectiveness of a single vaccination we also included six groups of four lambs each, vaccinated with O Manisa vaccine, 14 days prior to inoculation. Oropharyngeal fluid was obtained with a swab (OPF-swab), and blood samples were collected daily to determine virus excretion and serological response. We calculated the transmission rate beta (the number of new infections per day per infectious animal), and the reproduction ratio R (the number of secondary infections caused by one infectious individual). The mean daily virus excretion and the number of days the lambs excreted virus in the OPF differed significantly between vaccinated and non-vaccinated lambs. The transmission rate beta in the unvaccinated groups was 0.105 (95% confidence limit 0.044; 0.253) per day. The duration of the infectious period (T) was 21.11 (95% confidence limit 10.6; 42.1) days. With the final size of infection we estimated the reproduction ratio R in the non-vaccinated groups to be 1.14 (0.3; 3.3), and in vaccinated groups 0.22 (0.01; 1.78). Virus transmission as quantified by the final size did not differ statistically between the vaccinated and the non-vaccinated groups of lambs. In conclusion, FMDV seems able to persist in a sheep population, although the reproduction ratio was only slightly larger than one. As a consequence, vaccination might only have a small effect on transmission, in spite of the fact that virus excretion and duration of virus excretion is significantly reduced after vaccination.
众所周知,绵羊对口蹄疫病毒(FMDV)易感,但尚不清楚感染是否能在绵羊群体中传播和持续存在。因此,我们通过用FMD病毒O/NET/2001毒株对羔羊进行实验来量化病毒传播。我们使用了六组,每组四只羔羊,每组中一半接种,另一半进行接触暴露。为了量化单次疫苗接种的效果,我们还包括六组,每组四只羔羊,在接种前14天用O Manisa疫苗进行接种。用拭子采集口咽液(OPF拭子),每天采集血样以确定病毒排泄和血清学反应。我们计算了传播率β(每只感染动物每天的新感染数)和繁殖率R(由一个感染个体引起的二次感染数)。接种疫苗和未接种疫苗的羔羊在OPF中的平均每日病毒排泄量以及羔羊排泄病毒的天数存在显著差异。未接种疫苗组的传播率β为每天0.105(95%置信区间0.044;0.253)。感染期(T)的持续时间为21.11(95%置信区间10.6;42.1)天。根据最终感染规模,我们估计未接种疫苗组的繁殖率R为1.14(0.3;3.3),接种疫苗组为0.22(0.01;1.78)。通过最终感染规模量化的病毒传播在接种疫苗和未接种疫苗的羔羊组之间没有统计学差异。总之,尽管繁殖率仅略大于1,但FMDV似乎能够在绵羊群体中持续存在。因此,尽管接种疫苗后病毒排泄和病毒排泄持续时间显著减少,但疫苗接种可能对传播的影响很小。