Escobedo Francisco J, Wagner John E, Nowak David J, De la Maza Carmen Luz, Rodriguez Manuel, Crane Daniel E
University of Florida, IFAS-School of Forest Resources and Conservation, Building 164, Mowry Road, P.O. Box 110806, Gainesville, FL 32611-0806, USA.
J Environ Manage. 2008 Jan;86(1):148-57. doi: 10.1016/j.jenvman.2006.11.029. Epub 2007 Feb 1.
Santiago, Chile has the distinction of having among the worst urban air pollution problems in Latin America. As part of an atmospheric pollution reduction plan, the Santiago Regional Metropolitan government defined an environmental policy goal of using urban forests to remove particulate matter less than 10 microm (PM(10)) in the Gran Santiago area. We used cost effectiveness, or the process of establishing costs and selecting least cost alternatives for obtaining a defined policy goal of PM(10) removal, to analyze this policy goal. For this study, we quantified PM(10) removal by Santiago's urban forests based on socioeconomic strata and using field and real-time pollution and climate data via a dry deposition urban forest effects model. Municipal urban forest management costs were estimated using management cost surveys and Chilean Ministry of Planning and Cooperation documents. Results indicate that managing municipal urban forests (trees, shrubs, and grass whose management is under the jurisdiction of Santiago's 36 municipalities) to remove PM(10) was a cost-effective policy for abating PM(10) based on criteria set by the World Bank. In addition, we compared the cost effectiveness of managing municipal urban forests and street trees to other control policies (e.g. alternative fuels) to abate PM(10) in Santiago and determined that municipal urban forest management efficiency was similar to these other air quality improvement measures.
智利圣地亚哥在拉丁美洲城市空气污染问题最为严重的地区中榜上有名。作为大气污染减排计划的一部分,圣地亚哥地区首府政府制定了一项环境政策目标,即在大圣地亚哥地区利用城市森林去除直径小于10微米的颗粒物(PM10)。我们运用成本效益分析,即确定成本并选择成本最低的方案以实现去除PM10这一既定政策目标的过程,来分析这一政策目标。在本研究中,我们通过一个干沉降城市森林效应模型,基于社会经济阶层,并利用实地及实时污染和气候数据,对圣地亚哥城市森林去除PM10的情况进行了量化。利用管理成本调查和智利规划与合作部的文件估算了城市森林管理成本。结果表明,根据世界银行设定的标准,管理城市森林(树木、灌木和草地,其管理由圣地亚哥36个市负责)以去除PM10是一项具有成本效益的PM10减排政策。此外,我们将管理城市森林和行道树的成本效益与圣地亚哥其他控制政策(如替代燃料)进行了比较,以减少PM10,并确定城市森林管理效率与这些其他空气质量改善措施相似。