Bindoff I K, Tenni P C, Peterson G M, Kang B H, Jackson S L
School of Computing, University of Tasmania, Tasmania, Australia.
J Clin Pharm Ther. 2007 Feb;32(1):81-8. doi: 10.1111/j.1365-2710.2007.00801.x.
The aim was to develop and evaluate a pilot version of a knowledge-based system that can identify existing and potential medication-related problems from patient information. This intelligent system could directly support pharmacists and other health professionals providing medication reviews.
Rather than being based on static rules to trigger alerts, this system utilizes a multiple classification ripple-down rules approach, which allows the user to build rules incrementally and improve the accuracy of the knowledge base in identifying medication-related problems while the system is in use, with no outside assistance or training. The system contextualizes the potential drug therapy problems by taking into consideration the patient's demographics, and other medical condition and drugs. The system is capable of both being instructed in the domain of medication review through its routine use by an expert, and acting similarly to the expert when analysing genuine medication review cases. The system was handed over to an experienced clinical pharmacist (expert), with no knowledge or conclusions preloaded into the system. The expert was then able to add the case details and generate the rules required for 126 actual medication review cases.
Over 250 rules were generated from the review cases, incorporating demographics, medical history, symptoms, medications and pathology results from these cases. At the completion of the cases, more than 80% of the potential medication-related problems identified by the expert were also detected by the system. The false positive rate, or number of incorrect medication-related problems identified by the system, was <10% overall and was zero for the last 15 cases analysed. The system found significantly more potential medication-related problems than the expert, with the system consistently remaining at least one finding ahead. There was a high incidence of missed potential medication-related problems by the expert, which were automatically repaired by the system.
The knowledge-based system has already demonstrated that the technique employed is well suited to a domain of this nature and has furthermore demonstrated that it is capable of improving the quality of service that the medication reviewer can provide. The system will be further enhanced and tested prior to use in the field. It should help pharmacists in the provision of medication reviews, improving their clinical and time management capabilities, and enhancing their ability to contribute to the quality use of medications.
本研究旨在开发并评估一个基于知识的系统的试验版本,该系统能够从患者信息中识别现有的和潜在的与用药相关的问题。这个智能系统可以直接为药剂师和其他提供用药评估的医疗专业人员提供支持。
该系统并非基于触发警报的静态规则,而是采用了多重分类递推规则方法,允许用户在系统使用过程中逐步构建规则,并在无需外部协助或培训的情况下提高知识库识别与用药相关问题的准确性。该系统通过考虑患者的人口统计学信息、其他医疗状况和药物,将潜在的药物治疗问题置于具体情境中。该系统既能通过专家的日常使用在用药评估领域得到指导,又能在分析实际用药评估案例时表现得与专家类似。该系统交给了一位经验丰富的临床药剂师(专家),系统中没有预先加载任何知识或结论。然后,专家能够添加病例细节并生成126个实际用药评估案例所需的规则。
从这些评估案例中生成了250多条规则,涵盖了这些案例的人口统计学信息、病史、症状、用药情况和病理结果。在案例完成时,系统检测到了专家识别出的80%以上的潜在用药相关问题。系统识别出的错误用药相关问题的假阳性率,总体上<10%,在最后分析的15个案例中为零。系统发现的潜在用药相关问题比专家多得多,系统始终至少领先一项发现。专家遗漏潜在用药相关问题的发生率很高,而这些问题被系统自动修复。
基于知识的系统已经证明所采用的技术非常适合这种性质的领域,并且进一步证明它能够提高用药评估人员提供的服务质量。该系统在投入实际使用之前将进一步改进和测试。它应该有助于药剂师进行用药评估,提高他们的临床和时间管理能力,并增强他们对合理用药做出贡献的能力。