Cutcliffe J R, Koehn C V
University of Texas, Tyler, TX 75799, USA.
J Psychiatr Ment Health Nurs. 2007 Apr;14(2):141-7. doi: 10.1111/j.1365-2850.2007.01055.x.
This is the second of a two-part article which reports on a systematic review of the literature that focuses on hope (inspiring hope) within interpersonal (counselling) focused psychiatric/mental health (P/MH) nursing. Part one focused on the first three substantive areas, whereas this article focuses on the remaining areas and the discussion points arising out of the review. The discussion points arising are: (1) despite the increasing attention to hope over the last three decades, there remains a distinct paucity of research pertaining to P/MH nurses and hope, hoping and hopelessness; (2) the research that has been undertaken thus far lacks a cumulative, sequential progressive focus and has more of a sporadic, disparate look to it; (3) there is a dearth of empirical work to underpin specific interventions; (4) this relative absence of empirical work means that P/MH nurses often have to look to allied and/or related disciplines for their hope-related research; (5) there appears to be a disparity between the alleged importance of hope and the subsequent research activity; and (6) the research that does exist across different substantive areas appears to indicate that there might be common or shared basic psychosocial processes of hope inspiration, and thus the probability of a formal grounded theory; and this allows for idiosyncratic psychosocial processes for each substantive area. As a result of this review, the authors tentatively suggest that the inspiration of hope in P/MH nursing is grounded in the relationship established between nurse and person in need of hope, an emerging empirical finding that has obvious congruence and synchronicity with the philosophy and theory of a Peplauvian-based approach to P/MH nursing.
这是一篇分两部分的文章中的第二部分,该文章报道了一项文献系统综述,其聚焦于人际(咨询)导向的精神科/心理健康(P/MH)护理中的希望(激发希望)。第一部分聚焦于前三个实质性领域,而本文聚焦于其余领域以及综述中产生的讨论要点。产生的讨论要点如下:(1)尽管在过去三十年中对希望的关注日益增加,但关于P/MH护士与希望、怀有希望和绝望的研究仍然明显匮乏;(2)迄今为止所开展的研究缺乏累积性、循序渐进的重点,看起来更具零散性和差异性;(3)缺乏实证研究来支持具体干预措施;(4)实证研究的相对缺乏意味着P/MH护士常常不得不从相关及/或相关学科寻找与希望相关的研究;(5)希望的所谓重要性与后续研究活动之间似乎存在差距;(6)不同实质性领域现有的研究似乎表明,可能存在激发希望的共同或共享的基本社会心理过程,因此有可能形成一个正式的扎根理论;这也允许每个实质性领域存在独特的社会心理过程。作为本次综述的结果,作者初步认为,在P/MH护理中激发希望基于护士与需要希望的人之间建立的关系,这一新兴的实证发现与基于佩普劳理论的P/MH护理哲学和理论具有明显的一致性和同步性。