Frank Erica, Carrera Jennifer, Dharamsi Shafik
Department of Health Care and Epidemiology, University of British Columbia, Vancouver, BC, Canada.
J Gen Intern Med. 2007 Apr;22(4):514-7. doi: 10.1007/s11606-007-0108-5.
There have been no prior studies of the political self-characterization of U.S. physicians-in-training, and little is known about physicians' political leanings or the critical relationship between medical issues and political orientations of physicians and physicians-in-training.
All medical students in the class of 2003 at 16 nationally representative U.S. schools were eligible to complete three questionnaire administrations (at freshman orientation, entrance to wards, and senior year).
Among these medical students, 5% self-characterized as politically very conservative, 21% conservative, 33% moderate, 31% liberal, and 9% as very liberal." Being male, white, Protestant, intending to specialize in Surgery or anesthesiology/pathology/radiology, or currently or previously being married significantly (P < or = .001) increased the likelihood that a student self-identified as very conservative or conservative. Disagreement or strong disagreement with the statements, "I'm glad I chose to become a physician" and "Access to care is a fundamental human right," were also both associated with being very conservative or conservative. Being more liberal was reported by blacks and Hispanics; those intending to become ob-gyns, psychiatrists, and pediatric subspecialists; and atheists, Jews, and adherents of eastern religions.
U.S. medical students are considerably more likely to be liberal than conservative and are more likely to be liberal than are other young U.S. adults. Future U.S. physicians may be more receptive to liberal messages than conservative ones, and their political orientation may profoundly affect their health system attitudes.
此前尚无关于美国医学培训生政治自我认知的研究,对于医生的政治倾向以及医生和医学培训生的医疗问题与政治倾向之间的关键关系也知之甚少。
美国16所具有全国代表性的学校中2003级的所有医学生都有资格完成三次问卷调查(新生入学导向、进入病房实习和大四时)。
在这些医学生中,5%自我认定为政治上非常保守,21%为保守,33%为温和,31%为自由派,9%为非常自由派。男性、白人、新教徒、打算从事外科或麻醉学/病理学/放射学专业、目前或以前已婚的学生自我认定为非常保守或保守的可能性显著增加(P≤0.001)。对“我很高兴我选择成为一名医生”和“获得医疗服务是一项基本人权”这两个陈述表示不同意或强烈不同意,也都与非常保守或保守有关。黑人、西班牙裔;打算成为妇产科医生、精神科医生和儿科专科医生的人;以及无神论者、犹太人和东方宗教信徒报告称自己更倾向于自由派。
美国医学生比保守派更倾向于自由派,而且比其他美国年轻成年人更倾向于自由派。未来的美国医生可能更容易接受自由派的信息而非保守派的信息,他们的政治倾向可能会深刻影响他们对医疗系统的态度。