Martinez S, Marr J J
Faculty of Health Sciences, Department of Medicine, University of Cauca, Popayan, Colombia.
N Engl J Med. 1992 Mar 12;326(11):741-4. doi: 10.1056/NEJM199203123261105.
Pentavalent antimony, the generally accepted treatment for leishmaniasis, is given parenterally, and it is expensive and not readily available in developing countries. An inexpensive, orally administered compound would be a substantial advance in treatment. Previous studies in vitro have shown synergism between allopurinol and pentavalent antimony in tissue-culture systems. We designed this clinical study to determine whether synergism could be demonstrated in patients.
We performed a randomized, controlled study of the efficacy of allopurinol plus meglumine antimoniate (Glucantime), as compared with meglumine antimoniate alone, in patients with cutaneous leishmaniasis, who were recruited from a village in southeastern Colombia. In addition, those who declined injections were treated with allopurinol alone, and those who declined any treatment were considered controls. All the patients were followed for one year after the completion of treatment. Lesions that healed completely at three months and remained healed during follow-up were considered to be cured.
The cure rate for patients treated with meglumine antimoniate was 36 percent; the addition of allopurinol increased the rate to 74 percent (P less than 0.001). Treatment with allopurinol alone yielded a cure rate of 80 percent (P less than 0.001). There were no cures among the untreated patients. There was no significant difference between the cure rate with allopurinol plus meglumine antimoniate and that with allopurinol alone. No major toxic effects were observed.
For the treatment of American cutaneous leishmaniasis, the combination of allopurinol and meglumine antimoniate is significantly more effective than meglumine antimoniate alone, probably because of the efficacy of allopurinol alone, which appears to be as good as the combination.
五价锑是治疗利什曼病普遍认可的药物,需通过肠胃外给药,在发展中国家该药价格昂贵且不易获得。一种廉价的口服化合物将是治疗方面的重大进展。以往的体外研究表明,在组织培养系统中,别嘌呤醇与五价锑之间存在协同作用。我们开展这项临床研究以确定在患者身上是否能证实这种协同作用。
我们对别嘌呤醇加葡甲胺锑酸盐(葡醛锑钠)与单独使用葡甲胺锑酸盐治疗皮肤利什曼病的疗效进行了一项随机对照研究,患者来自哥伦比亚东南部的一个村庄。此外,拒绝注射治疗的患者单独使用别嘌呤醇治疗,拒绝任何治疗的患者被视为对照组。所有患者在完成治疗后随访一年。在三个月时完全愈合且在随访期间保持愈合的皮损被视为治愈。
接受葡甲胺锑酸盐治疗的患者治愈率为36%;加用别嘌呤醇后治愈率提高到74%(P<0.001)。单独使用别嘌呤醇治疗的治愈率为80%(P<0.001)。未治疗的患者无一治愈。别嘌呤醇加葡甲胺锑酸盐治疗的治愈率与单独使用别嘌呤醇治疗的治愈率之间无显著差异。未观察到重大毒性作用。
对于美洲皮肤利什曼病的治疗,别嘌呤醇与葡甲胺锑酸盐联合使用比单独使用葡甲胺锑酸盐显著更有效,这可能是因为别嘌呤醇单独使用就有效,其效果似乎与联合使用相当。