Fielingsdorf K, Dunn R N
Department of Orthopaedic Surgery, Stellenbosch University, Western Cape, South Africa.
S Afr Med J. 2007 Mar;97(3):203-7.
Cervical spinal cord injury (SCI) is a devastating event for the patient and family. It has a huge impact on society because of the intensive resources required to manage the patient in both the acute and rehabilitation phases. Given the resource-limited setting in South Africa, questions are often raised regarding whether the outcome of this group of patients justifies the expense of their care. However local data have not been available to date.
To evaluate the mortality, morbidity and functional outcome of cervical SCI patients in the South African environment.
All cervical SCI patients managed in the acute spinal cord injury unit at Groote Schuur Hospital over a 12-month period were included. Epidemiological data, management, complications, neurological status and change were assessed. Those referred for rehabilitation were followed up in terms of mortality and ambulation status.
There were 101 patients, with an average age of 34.7 years. Motor vehicle accidents were the commonest cause of injury, with violence contributing 21%. Fifty-nine patients required referral to a rehabilitation unit. Of these, 18 were functional walkers, and only 6 were care-dependent. By 1 year post injury all but 1 patient had been discharged from the health service. Fourteen patients died; in half of these cases injury was at C5 level and above.
Despite cervical SCI being a devastating event, aggressive early intervention yields a better-than-expected 1-year survival rate. Associated problems, such as pressure sores, remain a major problem both for the patient and in terms of health care costs. It is difficult to predict prognosis on presentation because of spinal shock. It is recommended that all patients initially be treated aggressively, with exit strategies in place once all the information is available and a confident assessment of poor prognosis can be made.
颈脊髓损伤(SCI)对患者及其家庭来说是一场灾难性事件。由于在急性期和康复期管理患者需要大量资源,所以它对社会有巨大影响。鉴于南非资源有限的情况,人们常常质疑这群患者的治疗结果是否值得投入如此高昂的护理费用。然而,目前尚无当地数据。
评估南非环境下颈脊髓损伤患者的死亡率、发病率和功能结局。
纳入在格罗特·舒尔医院急性脊髓损伤病房接受治疗超过12个月的所有颈脊髓损伤患者。评估流行病学数据、治疗、并发症、神经状态及变化情况。对转诊至康复机构的患者进行死亡率和行走状态随访。
共有101例患者,平均年龄34.7岁。机动车事故是最常见的致伤原因,暴力致伤占21%。59例患者需要转诊至康复机构。其中,18例能够功能性行走,仅6例需要依赖他人护理。伤后1年,除1例患者外,其余均已出院。14例患者死亡;其中半数患者损伤平面在C5及以上。
尽管颈脊髓损伤是一场灾难性事件,但积极的早期干预能带来优于预期的1年生存率。诸如压疮等相关问题,对患者及医疗费用而言仍是主要问题。由于脊髓休克,伤后难以预测预后。建议对所有患者最初都进行积极治疗,一旦掌握所有信息并能确定预后不良,便制定出院策略。