Parker S C, Kroboth F J
Department of Medicine, University of Pittsburgh School of Medicine, Pennsylvania.
J Gen Intern Med. 1991 Sep-Oct;6(5):430-5. doi: 10.1007/BF02598165.
Patient-satisfaction surveys have been used frequently to assess the humanistic behaviors and skills of internal medicine housestaff. In conducting their first such survey, the authors found that many practical problems affected the progress and outcome of the project. This discussion of the authors' experiences is intended to be helpful to others considering patient-satisfaction surveys as part of their housestaff-evaluation process.
A description of the practical aspects of conducting a patient-satisfaction survey as well as the problems that the authors encountered.
Both inpatient and outpatient settings at a major university internal medicine residency program.
PATIENTS/PARTICIPANTS: Ambulatory and hospitalized patients under the care of categorical internal medicine interns were eligible for participation in the study.
An established, validated patient-satisfaction questionnaire with high reported reliability was given to patients.
Although well over 90% of patients were willing to participate, 10% of participating outpatients and 16% of participating hospital patients could not provide a usable patient-satisfaction questionnaire even with assistance. Certain patient characteristics were responsible for these decreased completion rates. Among the hospitalized patients, 42% of all eligible patients were either too ill or too cognitively impaired to even be approached for participation in the study.
Patient-satisfaction surveys are labor-intensive, require significant resources, and are temporally demanding. Results from them must be viewed with certain caveats.
患者满意度调查常被用于评估内科住院医师的人文行为和技能。在开展首次此类调查时,作者发现许多实际问题影响了项目的进展和结果。本文对作者经验的讨论旨在帮助其他考虑将患者满意度调查作为住院医师评估过程一部分的人。
描述开展患者满意度调查的实际情况以及作者遇到的问题。
一所大型大学内科住院医师培训项目的住院和门诊科室。
患者/参与者:在内科分类实习医生照料下的门诊和住院患者有资格参与本研究。
向患者发放一份已确立且经过验证、报告可靠性高的患者满意度问卷。
尽管超过90%的患者愿意参与,但即便得到协助,仍有10%的参与调查的门诊患者和16%的参与调查的住院患者无法提供可用的患者满意度问卷。某些患者特征导致了这些较低的完成率。在住院患者中,所有符合条件的患者中有42%病情过重或认知障碍过于严重,甚至无法被邀请参与研究。
患者满意度调查劳动强度大,需要大量资源,且对时间要求高。对其结果必须谨慎看待。