Pearce Christopher, Dwan Kathryn, Arnold Michael, Phillips Christine
Department of General Practice, University of Melbourne, Carlton, Victoria, Australia.
Inform Prim Care. 2006;14(4):221-6.
This paper examines the utility of using digital video data in observational studies involving doctors' and patients' use of computers in the consultation. Previous observational studies have used either direct observations or analogue videotapes. We describe a method currently in use in a study examining how doctors, patients and computers interact in the consultation. The study is set in general practice as this is the most clinically computerised section of the Australian healthcare system. Computers are now used for clinical functions in 90% of doctors' surgeries. With this rapid rise of computerisation, concerns have been expressed as to how the computer will affect the doctor-patient relationship. To assess how doctors, patients and computers interact, we have chosen an observational technique, namely to make digital videotapes of actual consultations. This analysis is based on a theoretical framework derived from dramaturgical analysis. Data are gathered from general practitioners who are high-level users of computers, as defined by their use of progress notes, as well as prescribing and test ordering. The subsequent digital data is then transferred onto computer and analysed according to our conceptual framework, making use of video-tagging software.
本文探讨了在涉及医生和患者在诊疗过程中使用计算机的观察性研究中使用数字视频数据的效用。以往的观察性研究要么采用直接观察法,要么使用模拟录像带。我们描述了一种目前在一项研究中使用的方法,该研究考察医生、患者和计算机在诊疗过程中是如何互动的。这项研究以全科医疗为背景,因为这是澳大利亚医疗体系中临床计算机化程度最高的部分。现在,90%的医生诊疗室都将计算机用于临床功能。随着计算机化的迅速普及,人们对计算机将如何影响医患关系表示担忧。为了评估医生、患者和计算机之间的互动情况,我们选择了一种观察技术,即对实际诊疗过程进行数字录像。该分析基于一个源自戏剧化分析的理论框架。数据收集自那些根据其对病程记录、开处方和安排检查的使用情况而被界定为计算机高级用户的全科医生。随后,这些数字数据被传输到计算机上,并根据我们的概念框架,利用视频标记软件进行分析。