Lee Pyng, Brokx Hes A P, Postmus Pieter E, Sutedja Tom G
Department of Pulmonary Diseases, VU University Medical Centre, Amsterdam, The Netherlands.
Lung Cancer. 2007 Oct;58(1):44-9. doi: 10.1016/j.lungcan.2007.04.009. Epub 2007 May 29.
The incorporation of autofluorescence (AF) to white light bronchoscopy has led to improved sensitivity for the detection of pre-neoplastic lesions in the airways. However, AF has difficulty distinguishing benign epithelial changes such as bronchitis, previous biopsy, and airway fibrosis from pre-invasive lesions, which necessitates extensive biopsy. This frequently results in longer procedural time and need for additional sedation that may compromise patient safety, increase the risk of bronchospasm, and bleeding from multiple endobronchial biopsies. We postulate that dual imaging with simultaneous video and AF bronchoscopy of the tracheobronchial tree could improve the low specificity observed with AF in the detection of pre-invasive lesions, leading to targeted biopsy, good correlation with pathological diagnosis and shorter procedural time.
Forty-eight patients with known or suspected of lung cancer underwent video and AF bronchoscopy, which were provided as real-time dual images with SAFE 3000 (Pentax, Tokyo) between March and August 2006. Biopsy specimens were taken from all suspicious areas with two random specimens from normal areas. Values were expressed as median and range, and p<0.05 was considered statistically significant.
Twenty-five suspicious sites were detected by dual imaging bronchoscopy, and 126 endobronchial biopsies were evaluated, of which 22 (17.5%) were graded as moderate dysplasia and worse. Sensitivity and specificity of dual imaging for the detection of high-grade dysplasia were 86% and 94%, respectively, with good correlation between bronchoscopic assessment and pathology (r=0.77, p<0.0001). However, there were three random biopsy specimens obtained from normal or abnormal sites that showed severe dysplasia in two and moderate dysplasia in one. Median time taken for airway examination was 4 min (range, 4-4.8), and 5 min (range, 4-5) for biopsy, giving a total procedural time of 9 min (range, 8-10). There were no procedure-related complications noted.
Dual imaging that allows simultaneous real-time assessment of the lesion with video and AF bronchoscopy not only achieves satisfactory sensitivity for the detection of pre-neoplastic lesions, importantly it improves specificity by allowing targeted biopsy, which has led to a marked decrease in procedural time and better patient safety.
在白光支气管镜检查中加入自体荧光(AF)可提高气道中癌前病变检测的敏感性。然而,AF难以区分良性上皮变化,如支气管炎、既往活检和气道纤维化与浸润前病变,这就需要进行广泛的活检。这常常导致操作时间延长以及需要额外的镇静,而这可能会危及患者安全、增加支气管痉挛的风险以及多次支气管内活检导致的出血风险。我们推测,对气管支气管树进行同步视频和AF支气管镜的双重成像可以改善AF在浸润前病变检测中观察到的低特异性,从而实现靶向活检、与病理诊断的良好相关性以及缩短操作时间。
2006年3月至8月期间,48例已知或疑似肺癌的患者接受了视频和AF支气管镜检查,通过SAFE 3000(宾得,东京)提供实时双重图像。从所有可疑区域采集活检标本,并从正常区域随机采集两份标本。数值以中位数和范围表示,p<0.05被认为具有统计学意义。
通过双重成像支气管镜检测到25个可疑部位,共评估了126次支气管内活检,其中22次(17.5%)被评为中度发育异常及更严重病变。双重成像检测高级别发育异常的敏感性和特异性分别为86%和94%,支气管镜评估与病理之间具有良好的相关性(r=0.77,p<0.0001)。然而,从正常或异常部位获取的三份随机活检标本中,有两份显示为重度发育异常,一份显示为中度发育异常。气道检查的中位时间为4分钟(范围4 - 4.8分钟),活检时间为5分钟(范围4 - 5分钟),总操作时间为9分钟(范围8 - 10分钟)。未发现与操作相关的并发症。
双重成像允许通过视频和AF支气管镜对病变进行同步实时评估,不仅对癌前病变的检测具有令人满意的敏感性,重要的是通过允许靶向活检提高了特异性,这导致操作时间显著缩短并提高了患者安全性。