Wortley Pascale M, Levy Paul S, Quick Linda, Shoemaker Trevor R, Dahlke Melissa A, Evans Brian, Burke Brian, Schwartz Benjamin
National Center for Immunization and Respiratory Diseases, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, 1600 Clifton Road, Atlanta, GA 30333, USA.
Am J Prev Med. 2007 Jun;32(6):538-41. doi: 10.1016/j.amepre.2007.02.002.
The goal of the National Smallpox Vaccination Program was to vaccinate a cadre of healthcare workers and first responders who could care for smallpox patients in the event of an attack.
Using a convenience sample of 36 health departments and 34 hospitals in California, we conducted a telephone interview between July 2003 and April 2004 of healthcare workers and first responders to determine predictors of smallpox vaccination.
The response rate was 54.1%. Of 477 respondents with no contraindications to vaccination, 106 were vaccinated and 371 were unvaccinated. Among the vaccinated, the leading reason for vaccination was wanting to be part of a smallpox response team (74%). Among the unvaccinated, leading reasons for not being vaccinated included thinking the risk of smallpox was not high enough (25%) and concern about side effects (19%). Factors independently associated with vaccination include previous smallpox vaccination (adjusted odds ratio [AOR]=4.1, 95% confidence interval [CI]=1.2-14.1), having little or no concern about vaccine adverse events (AOR=3.0, CI=1.3-7.0, compared with somewhat/very), reporting their employer had a policy to reimburse for travel or other out of pocket costs (AOR=2.5, CI=1.1-5.7, compared with no policy), very high to high chance of compensation if adverse events occurred (AOR=2.9, CI=1.2-6.3, compared with low chance), and answering in the negative to questions about concerns about potential costs. Blacks were less likely than whites to be vaccinated (AOR=0.04, CI=0.03-0.6).
Clearly communicating the risks and benefits of vaccination and addressing issues of cost, convenience, and compensation may be important for any program where vaccination is provided in the national interest and when the direct benefits of vaccination are unknown.
国家天花疫苗接种计划的目标是为一批医护人员和急救人员接种疫苗,以便在发生天花袭击时能够照料天花患者。
我们选取了加利福尼亚州36个卫生部门和34家医院作为便利样本,在2003年7月至2004年4月期间对医护人员和急救人员进行了电话访谈,以确定天花疫苗接种的预测因素。
回复率为54.1%。在477名无接种禁忌的受访者中,106人接种了疫苗,371人未接种。在接种者中,接种的主要原因是希望成为天花应对团队的一员(74%)。在未接种者中,未接种的主要原因包括认为天花风险不够高(25%)和担心副作用(19%)。与接种相关的独立因素包括既往接种过天花疫苗(调整后的优势比[AOR]=4.1,95%置信区间[CI]=1.2~14.1),对疫苗不良事件几乎不担心或完全不担心(与有些担心/非常担心相比,AOR=3.0,CI=1.3~7.0),报告其雇主有报销差旅费或其他自付费用的政策(与无政策相比,AOR=2.5,CI=1.1~5.7),如果发生不良事件获得高额至高额赔偿的可能性很大(与可能性低相比,AOR=2.9,CI=1.2~6.3),以及对潜在成本担忧问题的回答为否。黑人接种疫苗的可能性低于白人(AOR=0.04,CI=0.03~0.6)。
对于任何出于国家利益提供疫苗接种且疫苗接种的直接益处未知的计划而言,清晰地传达疫苗接种的风险和益处以及解决成本、便利性和赔偿问题可能很重要。