Ingham Graham
68 Parish Ghyll Drive, Ilkley, LS29 9PR, UK.
Int J Psychoanal. 2007 Jun;88(Pt 3):753-68. doi: 10.1516/a817-0367-7503-g228.
The author notes that the concepts of the superego and narcissism were linked at conception and that superego pathology may be seen as a determining factor in the formation of a narcissistic disorder; thus an examination of the superego can function as a "biopsy", indicating the condition of the personality as a whole. Charles Dickens's novel "Great Expectations" is presented as a penetrating exploration of these themes and it is argued that in Pip, the central character, Dickens provides a perceptive study of the history of a narcissistic condition. Other key figures in the book are understood as superego representations and, as such, integral to the vicissitudes of Pip's development. In particular, the lawyer Jaggers is considered as an illustration of Bion's notion of the "ego-destructive superego". In the course of the paper, the author suggests that Great Expectations affirms the psychoanalytic understanding that emotional growth and some recovery from narcissistic difficulties necessarily take place alongside modification of the superego, allowing for responsible knowledge of the state of the object and the possibility of realistic reparation.
作者指出,超我和自恋的概念在其诞生之时便相互关联,超我病理学可被视为自恋性障碍形成的一个决定性因素;因此,对超我的审视可起到“活检”的作用,揭示整个人格的状况。查尔斯·狄更斯的小说《远大前程》被视作对这些主题的深刻探索,有人认为,在小说的核心人物皮普身上,狄更斯对一种自恋状况的发展历程进行了敏锐的研究。书中的其他关键人物被理解为超我的代表,因此,他们对于皮普成长过程中的兴衰变迁至关重要。尤其是,律师贾格斯被视为对拜昂“自我毁灭超我”概念的例证。在论文中,作者认为,《远大前程》证实了精神分析学的一种理解,即情感成长以及从自恋困境中有所恢复必然伴随着超我的改变,从而能够对客体状态有负责任的认知,并实现现实层面的修复。