Binhas M, Krakowski I, Marty J
Service d'anesthésie réanimation chirurgicale, hôpital Henri-Mondor, université Paris-XII, Créteil, France.
Ann Fr Anesth Reanim. 2007 Jun;26(6):502-15. doi: 10.1016/j.annfar.2007.03.029. Epub 2007 Jun 8.
The World Health Organization (WHO) published guidelines to improve cancer pain control which allow to relieve noceptive cancer pain in 80% of adult patients. Nevertheless WHO recommendations do not include: various ways to start morphine treatment, how to manage opioids adverse effects, severe cancer pain management, postoperative pain and procedure-relatived pain. The goal of this review is to discuss these issues.
The data were retrieved from PubMed years 2001 to 2006 (keywords used alone or in combination were: opioids, cancer, pain, pain killers, rotation, intraspinal, ketamine, side effects), the "Standard, Options and Recommendations on cancer nociceptive pain treatments for adult patients" published by the French Union of Comprehensive Cancer Centers (FNCLCC; Fédération nationale des centres de lutte contre le cancer) and the European Association for Palliative Care (EAPC) recommendations on morphine and alternative opioids in cancer pain. Data also include an analysis of studies before 2001 which give information about the pharmacokinetic data of transdermal and transmucosal fentanyl.
Studies written in English or French related to the medical treatments (commercialized in France) for nociceptive cancer pain for adult patients were analyzed. Analyzed articles were clinical or experimental studies or metaanalyses. Studies on neuropathic cancer pain, editorials and letters to the editor were discarded.
Nociceptive cancer pain is characterized by its frequent instability. More than 50% of patients have paroxystic painful accesses (PPA), either spontaneous or induced by care or mobilizations. Morphine is the main treatment but the prescription of controlled-release morphine must be associated with the prescription of immediate-release morphine to treat the PPA or to transmucosal fentanyl which has a faster onset of action than immediate-release morphine. Morphine treatment can be introduced either by immediate-release morphine or by controlled-release morphine. The introduction of immediate-release morphine is recommended for old or fragile patients, patients with denutrition, hepatic or renal failure. For patients suffering unbearable side effects under morphine or morphine resistant pain, opioid rotation or intravenous morphine or fentanyl are recommended. Spinal opioids administration (by epidural or intrathecal routes) is most often indicated in patients with very severe and resistant pain in terminal disease. In the postoperative period, previous pain treatment must be maintained or increased. Pain bounded to care procedures must be prevented with various and associated treatments: for example, mixed topics lidocaïne-prilocaine for venous or arterial punctures; infiltration of local anaesthetics and inhalation of an oxygen - nitrous oxide mixture for medullary biopsies.
Oral immediate or controlled release morphine is the most common and effective pain treatment for most patients with nociceptive cancer pain but rotation with other opioids or alternative routes of administration must be discussed quickly if pain persits or if adverse effects occur.
世界卫生组织(WHO)发布了改善癌症疼痛控制的指南,该指南旨在使80%的成年患者的伤害感受性癌痛得到缓解。然而,WHO的建议未涵盖:启动吗啡治疗的各种方法、如何处理阿片类药物的不良反应、重度癌痛的管理、术后疼痛及与诊疗操作相关的疼痛。本综述的目的是讨论这些问题。
数据检索自2001年至2006年的PubMed(单独或组合使用的关键词有:阿片类药物、癌症、疼痛、止痛药、轮换、脊髓内、氯胺酮、副作用)、法国综合癌症中心联盟(FNCLCC;Fédération nationale des centres de lutte contre le cancer)发布的“成年患者癌症伤害感受性疼痛治疗的标准、选择及建议”以及欧洲姑息治疗协会(EAPC)关于癌症疼痛中吗啡及替代阿片类药物的建议。数据还包括对2001年之前的研究分析,这些研究提供了透皮和黏膜芬太尼的药代动力学数据。
分析了用英文或法文撰写的、与成年患者伤害感受性癌痛的医学治疗(在法国上市)相关的研究。分析的文章为临床研究、实验研究或荟萃分析。有关神经性癌痛的研究、社论及读者来信被排除。
伤害感受性癌痛的特点是频繁不稳定。超过50%的患者有阵发性疼痛发作(PPA),可为自发的,或由护理或活动诱发。吗啡是主要治疗药物,但控释吗啡的处方必须与即释吗啡的处方联合使用,以治疗PPA,或使用起效比即释吗啡更快的黏膜芬太尼。吗啡治疗可通过即释吗啡或控释吗啡开始。对于老年或体弱患者、营养不良患者、肝或肾功能衰竭患者,建议采用即释吗啡开始治疗。对于在吗啡治疗下出现难以忍受的副作用或吗啡耐药性疼痛的患者,建议进行阿片类药物轮换或使用静脉注射吗啡或芬太尼。脊髓阿片类药物给药(通过硬膜外或鞘内途径)最常用于终末期疾病中疼痛非常严重且耐药的患者。在术后阶段,必须维持或增加先前的疼痛治疗。必须通过多种联合治疗预防与诊疗操作相关的疼痛:例如,静脉或动脉穿刺时使用利多卡因 - 丙胺卡因混合剂;骨髓活检时局部麻醉药浸润并吸入氧气 - 一氧化二氮混合气体。
口服即释或控释吗啡是大多数伤害感受性癌痛患者最常用且有效的疼痛治疗方法,但如果疼痛持续或出现不良反应,必须尽快讨论与其他阿片类药物的轮换或其他给药途径。