Buss Mary K, Lessen David S, Sullivan Amy M, Von Roenn Jamie, Arnold Robert M, Block Susan D
Harvard Medical School, Boston, Massachusetts, USA.
J Support Oncol. 2007 May;5(5):237-42.
Caring for the dying is a core competency for oncologists, yet the quality of oncology fellowship training in end-of-life (EOL) care has not been assessed. A convenience sample of physicians attending the 2004 annual meeting of the American Society of Clinical Oncology responded to a 112-item questionnaire that assessed fellows' knowledge and education about EOL care. Of the 120 respondents, 107 (89%) rated caring for dying patients as"quite" or "very important. "Forty-two percent of the fellows rated the overall quality of teaching EOL care in their fellowship as "very good" or "excellent," whereas 23% gave such ratings to EOL teaching in fellowship (P < or = 0.001). Fellows viewed attending oncologists as having more expertise in dealing with acute complications of cancer (eg, managing spinal cord compression, 78%) than in delivering EOL care (eg, managing pain, 54%; P < 0.001). Fellows also were more likely to have received observation and feedback on bone marrow biopsies than on EOL discussions. Knowledge about key EOL care topics was poor; only 31% correctly performed an opioid conversion. Oncology fellows described deficiencies in training on EOL issues;they may benefit from improved education on EOL topics.
关爱临终患者是肿瘤学家的一项核心能力,但临终关怀方面的肿瘤学专科培训质量尚未得到评估。参加2004年美国临床肿瘤学会年会的医生组成的便利样本,对一份包含112个项目的问卷做出了回应,该问卷评估了专科住院医生关于临终关怀的知识和教育情况。在120名受访者中,107人(89%)将关爱临终患者评为“相当”或“非常重要”。42%的专科住院医生将其专科培训中临终关怀教学的整体质量评为“非常好”或“优秀”,而将专科培训中的临终关怀教学评为如此的比例为23%(P≤0.001)。专科住院医生认为,主治肿瘤医生在处理癌症急性并发症(如处理脊髓压迫,78%)方面比在提供临终关怀(如控制疼痛,54%;P<0.001)方面更具专业知识。与临终关怀讨论相比,专科住院医生也更有可能接受过关于骨髓活检的观察和反馈。关于关键临终关怀主题的知识掌握得很差;只有31%的人能正确进行阿片类药物转换。肿瘤学专科住院医生描述了临终关怀问题培训方面的不足;他们可能会从改进的临终关怀主题教育中受益。