Saudino K J, Eaton W O
Department of Psychology, University of Manitoba, Winnipeg, Canada.
Child Dev. 1991 Oct;62(5):1167-74.
Child temperament theories generally presume genetic contributions to behavioral differences, but empirical support is based largely on parent ratings of twins. These subjective ratings may be biased by parental exaggeration of dizygotic differences or of monozygotic similarities. An objective assessment of the genetic hypothesis was undertaken with motor activity level, a core dimension of most temperament theories. The activity level of 60 infant twin pairs was measured both by parent ratings and by motion recorders over a 2-day period. Data from the motion recorders showed evidence of genetic influences (RMZ = .76, RDZ = .56), as did parent ratings (RMZ = .82, RDZ = .21). The motion recorder results confirm with instrumentation a critical assumption of temperament theories and identify the presence of genetic contributors to temperamentally relevant behavioral differences in infancy.
儿童气质理论通常假定行为差异有遗传因素,但实证支持主要基于父母对双胞胎的评价。这些主观评价可能因父母夸大异卵双胞胎的差异或同卵双胞胎的相似性而产生偏差。我们采用运动活动水平对遗传假说进行了客观评估,运动活动水平是大多数气质理论的一个核心维度。在为期两天的时间里,通过父母评价和运动记录仪对60对婴儿双胞胎的活动水平进行了测量。运动记录仪的数据显示出遗传影响的证据(同卵双胞胎相关系数=0.76,异卵双胞胎相关系数=0.56),父母评价的数据也是如此(同卵双胞胎相关系数=0.82,异卵双胞胎相关系数=0.21)。运动记录仪的结果通过仪器证实了气质理论的一个关键假设,并确定了遗传因素在婴儿期与气质相关的行为差异中的存在。