Spocter Muhammad A, Manger Paul R
School of Anatomical Sciences, Faculty of Health Sciences, University of the Witwatersrand, 7 York Road, Parktown 2193, Johannesburg, South Africa.
Am J Phys Anthropol. 2007 Sep;134(1):92-105. doi: 10.1002/ajpa.20641.
Estimating body mass/size/weight remains a crucial precursor to the evaluation of relative brain size and to achieving an understanding of brain evolution in fossil species. Despite the obvious close association between the metrics of postcranial elements and body mass a number of factors combine to reduce their utility. This study examines the feasibility of cranial variables for predicting body mass. The use of traditional regression procedures, independent contrasts analysis, and variance partitioning all support the hypothesis that cranial variables are correlated with body mass even when taking phylogeny into account, with r values typically ranging between 0.52 and 0.98. Body mass estimates derived for fossil hominins using cranial variables are similar to those obtained from previous studies using either cranial or postcranial elements. In particular, upper facial breadth and orbital height display strong predictive capability. Average body masses derived from Least Squares Regression (LSR) equations were used to calculate estimates of body mass for three hominin species. This resulted in estimates of between 30 kg and 47 kg for Australopithecus africanus, 48 kg and 52 kg for Paranthropus robustus, and 75 kg for Homo neanderthalensis. It is proposed that regression equations derived for the order primates are used to estimate body mass for archaic hominins, while hominoid based equations are most suited for Homo.
估算身体质量/大小/重量仍然是评估相对脑容量以及理解化石物种脑进化的关键前提。尽管颅后骨骼元素的测量指标与身体质量之间存在明显的紧密联系,但多种因素综合起来降低了它们的实用性。本研究考察了颅骨变量用于预测身体质量的可行性。使用传统回归程序、独立对比分析和方差分解均支持这样的假设:即使考虑系统发育,颅骨变量也与身体质量相关,相关系数r值通常在0.52至0.98之间。使用颅骨变量得出的化石人类身体质量估计值与先前使用颅骨或颅后骨骼元素的研究结果相近。特别是,上颌宽度和眶高显示出很强的预测能力。利用最小二乘法回归(LSR)方程得出的平均身体质量被用于计算三种人类物种的身体质量估计值。这得出非洲南方古猿的估计值在30千克至47千克之间,粗壮傍人的估计值在48千克至52千克之间,以及尼安德特人的估计值为75千克。有人提出,为灵长目推导的回归方程用于估算古代人类的身体质量,而基于类人猿的方程最适合用于智人。