Howard A Fuchsia, Balneaves Lynda G, Bottorff Joan L
School of Nursing, University of British Columbia, Vancouver.
Cancer Nurs. 2007 Jul-Aug;30(4):E27-35. doi: 10.1097/01.NCC.0000281737.33232.3c.
A growing number of studies have been conducted that explore the breast cancer experiences of women from diverse ethnocultural groups. To advance knowledge and provide a foundation for future research, a synthesis was conducted of 15 qualitative research studies focusing on women from ethnocultural groups diagnosed with breast cancer. A qualitative meta-study approach was used that included analysis of the theoretical orientations and methodological approaches underlying the research, and an interpretive synthesis of research findings. Ethnocultural groups represented in the studies included Asian American, Aboriginal, Hispanic, and African American women. The synthesis revealed diverse experiences within and among these ethnocultural groups represented in 5 major themes: (a) the "othered" experience of a breast cancer diagnosis, (b) the treatment experience as "other," (c) losses associated with breast cancer, (d) the family context of breast cancer experiences, and (e) coping with cancer through spirituality and community involvement. The integration of findings from the 15 studies also revealed how methodological and theoretical approaches to conducting this research influenced understandings of the experiences of breast cancer. Further experiential breast cancer research with ethnocultural groups is needed, as well as the use of research methods that illuminate the ways that ethnicity, class, age, and gender relations are played out in healthcare settings.
越来越多的研究开始探索不同种族文化群体中女性的乳腺癌经历。为了增进知识并为未来研究奠定基础,对15项定性研究进行了综合分析,这些研究聚焦于被诊断患有乳腺癌的种族文化群体中的女性。采用了定性元研究方法,包括分析研究背后的理论取向和方法论方法,以及对研究结果的解释性综合。研究中所代表的种族文化群体包括亚裔美国人、原住民、西班牙裔和非裔美国女性。综合分析揭示了这些种族文化群体内部和之间的不同经历,主要体现在5个主题中:(a)乳腺癌诊断的“他者化”经历;(b)作为“他者”的治疗经历;(c)与乳腺癌相关的损失;(d)乳腺癌经历的家庭背景;(e)通过灵性和社区参与应对癌症。对这15项研究结果的整合还揭示了开展此项研究的方法论和理论方法如何影响对乳腺癌经历的理解。需要对种族文化群体进一步开展乳腺癌体验研究,以及运用能阐明种族、阶级、年龄和性别关系在医疗环境中如何呈现的研究方法。