Neumark Thomas, Mölstad Sigvard, Rosén Christer, Persson Lars-Göran, Törngren Annika, Brudin Lars, Eliasson Ingvar
Lindsdal Primary Health Centre, Kalmar, Sweden.
Scand J Prim Health Care. 2007 Sep;25(3):166-71. doi: 10.1080/02813430701267405.
To study the clinical recovery from acute otitis media (AOM) in children, 2-16 years of age, managed with or without treatment with phenoxymethylpenicillin (PcV).
An open, prospective randomized trial. Children aged between 2 and 16 years, presenting with one- or double-sided AOM (without perforation) with symptom duration of less than four days, were included. The children were randomized to PcV for five days or to no primary antibiotic treatment. A health score and compliance were registered on a daily basis for seven days.
A total of 32 health centres and 72 GPs in south-east Sweden. Subjects. Children aged 2-16 presenting with earache.
Recovery time, symptom duration, frequency of complications (up to three months) and consumption of healthcare services independent of treatment with or without antibiotics.
A total of 179 patients carried out the trial; 92 were randomized to PcV, 87 to no primary antibiotic treatment. The median recovery time was four days in both groups. Patients who received PcV had less pain (p <0.001) and used fewer analgesics. There were no significant differences in the number of middle-ear effusions or perforations at the final control after three months. Children randomized to PcV treatment consulted less (p <0.001) during the first seven days.
Our investigation supports that PcV treatment of AOM does not affect the recovery time or complication rates. PcV provided some symptomatic benefit in the treatment of AOM in otherwise healthy children, aged 2-16 years.
研究2至16岁儿童急性中耳炎(AOM)在接受或不接受苯氧甲基青霉素(PcV)治疗后的临床恢复情况。
一项开放性前瞻性随机试验。纳入2至16岁、单侧或双侧AOM(无穿孔)且症状持续时间少于4天的儿童。将儿童随机分为接受5天PcV治疗组或不进行初始抗生素治疗组。连续7天每天记录健康评分和依从性。
瑞典东南部的32个健康中心和72名全科医生。研究对象:2至16岁出现耳痛的儿童。
恢复时间、症状持续时间、并发症发生率(长达3个月)以及与是否接受抗生素治疗无关的医疗服务使用情况。
共有179名患者完成试验;92名被随机分配至PcV治疗组,87名被随机分配至不进行初始抗生素治疗组。两组的中位恢复时间均为4天。接受PcV治疗的患者疼痛较轻(p<0.001)且使用的镇痛药较少。3个月后最终检查时中耳积液或穿孔的数量无显著差异。随机接受PcV治疗的儿童在头7天内就诊次数较少(p<0.001)。
我们的研究支持,PcV治疗AOM不影响恢复时间或并发症发生率。对于2至16岁的健康儿童,PcV在治疗AOM时具有一定的症状改善作用。