Kong Weidong, Zhang-Salomons Jina, Hanna Timothy P, Mackillop William J
Division of Cancer Care and Epidemiology, Queen's University Cancer Research Institute, Kingston, Ontario, Canada.
Int J Radiat Oncol Biol Phys. 2007 Nov 15;69(4):1209-17. doi: 10.1016/j.ijrobp.2007.04.048.
To describe the use of palliative radiotherapy (PRT) for bone metastases in Ontario between 1984 and 2001 and identify factors associated with the choice of fractionation.
Electronic RT records from the nine provincial RT centers in Ontario were linked to the Ontario Cancer Registry to identify all courses of PRT for bone metastases.
Between 1984 and 2001, 44,884 patients received 74,432 courses of PRT for bone metastases in Ontario. The mean number of courses per patient was 1.7, and 65% of patients received only a single course of PRT for bone metastasis. The mean number of fractions per course was 3.9. The proportion of patients treated with a single fraction increased from 27.2% in 1984-1986 to 40.3% in 1987-1992 and decreased thereafter. Single fractions were used more frequently in patients with a shorter life expectancy, in older patients, and in patients who lived further from an RT center. Single fractions were used more frequently when the prevailing waiting time for RT was longer. There were wide variations in the use of single fractions among the different RT centers (intercenter range, 11.8-62.3%). Intercenter variations persisted throughout the study period and were not explained by differences in case mix.
Despite increasing evidence of the effectiveness of single-fraction PRT for bone metastases, most patients continued to receive fractionated PRT throughout the two decades of this study. Single fractions were used more frequently when waiting times were longer. There was persistent, unexplained variation in the fractionation of PRT among different centers.
描述1984年至2001年间安大略省姑息性放射治疗(PRT)用于骨转移瘤的情况,并确定与分割方式选择相关的因素。
安大略省九个省级放疗中心的电子放疗记录与安大略癌症登记处相链接,以识别所有用于骨转移瘤的PRT疗程。
1984年至2001年间,安大略省有44884例患者接受了74432个骨转移瘤PRT疗程。每位患者的平均疗程数为1.7,65%的患者仅接受了一个骨转移瘤PRT疗程。每个疗程的平均分割次数为3.9。单次分割治疗的患者比例从1984 - 1986年的27.2%增至1987 - 1992年的40.3%,此后下降。预期寿命较短的患者、老年患者以及居住距离放疗中心较远的患者更常采用单次分割。当放疗的普遍等待时间较长时,单次分割使用更为频繁。不同放疗中心在单次分割的使用上存在很大差异(中心间范围为11.8% - 62.3%)。中心间差异在整个研究期间持续存在,且不能用病例组合差异来解释。
尽管有越来越多的证据表明单次分割PRT对骨转移瘤有效,但在本研究的二十年中,大多数患者仍继续接受分割PRT。等待时间较长时,单次分割使用更为频繁。不同中心在PRT分割方式上存在持续的、无法解释的差异。