Uera Raynato B, Paz-Alberto Annie Melinda, Sigua Gilbert C
Environmental Management Department, Institute of Graduate Studies, Central Luzon State University, Science City of Muñoz, Nueva Ecija, Philippines 3120.
Environ Sci Pollut Res Int. 2007 Nov;14(7):505-9. doi: 10.1065/espr2007.02.391.
BACKGROUND, AIMS AND SCOPE: Research and development has its own benefits and inconveniences. One of the inconveniences is the generation of enormous quantity of diverse toxic and hazardous wastes and its eventual contamination to soil and groundwater resources. Ethidium bromide (EtBr) is one of the commonly used substances in molecular biology experiments. It is highly mutagenic and moderately toxic substance used in DNA-staining during electrophoresis. Interest in phytoremediation as a method to solve chemical contamination has been growing rapidly in recent years. The technology has been utilized to clean up soil and groundwater from heavy metals and other toxic organic compounds in many countries like the United States, Russia, and most of European countries. Phytoremediation requires somewhat limited resources and very useful in treating wide variety of environmental contaminants. This study aimed to assess the potential of selected tropical plants as phytoremediators of EtBr.
This study used tomato (Solanum lycopersicum), mustard (Brassica alba), vetivergrass (Vetiveria zizanioedes), cogongrass (Imperata cylindrica), carabaograss (Paspalum conjugatum), and talahib (Saccharum spontaneum) to remove EtBr from laboratory wastes. The six tropical plants were planted in individual plastic bags containing soil and 10% EtBr-stained agarose gel. The plants were allowed to establish and grow in soil for 30 days. Ethidium bromide content of the test plants and the soil were analyzed before and after soil treatment. Ethidium bromide contents of the plants and soils were analyzed using an UV VIS spectrophotometer.
Results showed a highly significant (p< or =0.001) difference in the ability of the tropical plants to absorb EtBr from soils. Mustard registered the highest absorption of EtBr (1.4+/-0.12 microg kg(-1)) followed by tomato and vetivergrass with average uptake of 1.0+/-0.23 and 0.7+/-0.17 microg kg(-1) EtBr, respectively. Cogongrass, talahib, and carabaograss had the least amount of EtBr absorbed (0.2+/-0.6 microg kg(-1)). Ethidium bromide content of soil planted to mustard was reduced by 10.7%. This was followed by tomato with an average reduction of 8.1%. Only 5.6% reduction was obtained from soils planted to vetivergrass. Soils planted to cogongrass, talahib, and carabaograss had the least reduction of 1.52% from its initial EtBr content.
In this study, mustard, tomato, and vetivergrass have shown their ability to absorb EtBr from contaminated soil keeping them from expanding their reach into the environment and preventing further contamination. Its downside, however, is that living creatures including humans, fish, and birds, must be prevented from eating the plants that utilized these substances. Nonetheless, it is still easier to isolate, cut down, and remove plants growing on the surface of the contaminated matrices, than to use strong acids and permanganates to chemically neutralize a dangerous process that can further contaminate the environment and pose additional risks to humans. Though this alternative method does not totally eliminate eventual environmental contamination, it is by far produces extremely insignificant amount of by-products compared with the existing processes and technologies.
Mustard had the highest potential as phytoremediator of EtBr in soil. However, the absorption capabilities of the other test plants may also be considered in terms of period of maturity and productivity.
It is recommended that a more detailed and complete investigation of the phytoremediation properties of the different plants tested should be conducted in actual field experiments. Plants should be exposed until they reach maturity to establish their maximum response to the toxicity and mutagenecity of EtBr and their maximum absorbing capabilities. Different plant parts should be analyzed individually to determine the movement and translocation of EtBr from soil to the tissues of plants. Since this study has established that some plants can thrive and dwell in EtBr-treated soil, an increased amount of EtBr application should be explored in future studies. It is suggested therefore that a larger, more comprehensive exploration of phytoremediation application in the management of toxic and hazardous wastes emanating from biotechnology research activities should be considered especially on the use of vetivergrass, a very promising tropical perennial grass.
背景、目的和范围:研发有其自身的益处和不便之处。不便之一是产生大量种类繁多的有毒有害废物,以及这些废物最终对土壤和地下水资源造成的污染。溴化乙锭(EtBr)是分子生物学实验中常用的物质之一。它是一种高致突变性且具有中等毒性的物质,用于电泳过程中的DNA染色。近年来,作为一种解决化学污染的方法,植物修复受到的关注迅速增加。在美国、俄罗斯以及大多数欧洲国家等许多国家,该技术已被用于清理土壤和地下水中的重金属及其他有毒有机化合物。植物修复所需资源相对有限,在处理各种环境污染物方面非常有用。本研究旨在评估选定的热带植物作为溴化乙锭植物修复剂的潜力。
本研究使用番茄(Solanum lycopersicum)、芥菜(Brassica alba)、香根草(Vetiveria zizanioedes)、白茅(Imperata cylindrica)、大黍(Paspalum conjugatum)和莎草(Saccharum spontaneum)从实验室废物中去除溴化乙锭。将这六种热带植物种植在装有土壤和10%溴化乙锭染色琼脂糖凝胶的单独塑料袋中。让植物在土壤中生长30天以使其扎根并生长。在土壤处理前后分析受试植物和土壤中的溴化乙锭含量。使用紫外可见分光光度计分析植物和土壤中的溴化乙锭含量。
结果表明,热带植物从土壤中吸收溴化乙锭的能力存在极显著差异(p≤0.001)。芥菜对溴化乙锭的吸收量最高(1.4±0.12微克/千克),其次是番茄和香根草,平均吸收量分别为1.0±0.23微克/千克和0.7±0.17微克/千克溴化乙锭。白茅、莎草和大黍吸收的溴化乙锭量最少(0.2±0.6微克/千克)。种植芥菜的土壤中溴化乙锭含量降低了10.7%。其次是番茄,平均降低8.1%。种植香根草的土壤仅降低了5.6%。种植白茅、莎草和大黍的土壤中,其初始溴化乙锭含量降低最少,为1.52%。
在本研究中,芥菜、番茄和香根草已显示出从污染土壤中吸收溴化乙锭的能力,从而防止其扩散到环境中并防止进一步污染。然而,其不利之处在于,必须防止包括人类、鱼类和鸟类在内的生物食用利用这些物质的植物。尽管如此,与使用强酸和高锰酸盐进行化学中和这种可能进一步污染环境并给人类带来额外风险的危险过程相比,隔离、砍伐和清除生长在受污染基质表面的植物仍然更容易。虽然这种替代方法不能完全消除最终的环境污染,但与现有工艺和技术相比,它产生的副产品数量极少。
芥菜作为土壤中溴化乙锭的植物修复剂潜力最大。然而,从成熟周期和生产力方面考虑,也可考虑其他受试植物的吸收能力。
建议在实际田间试验中对不同受试植物的植物修复特性进行更详细和全面的研究。应让植物生长至成熟,以确定它们对溴化乙锭的毒性和致突变性的最大反应以及最大吸收能力。应分别分析植物的不同部位,以确定溴化乙锭从土壤到植物组织的移动和转运情况。由于本研究已确定一些植物能够在经溴化乙锭处理的土壤中生长和存活,因此在未来研究中应探索增加溴化乙锭的施用量。因此,建议尤其针对香根草这种非常有前景的热带多年生草本植物,对植物修复在生物技术研究活动产生的有毒有害废物管理中的应用进行更广泛、更全面的探索。