Zapka Jane, Lemon Stephenie C, Estabrook Barbara B, Jolicoeur Denise G
Medical University of South Carolina, 135 Cannon Street, P.O. Box 250835, Charleston, SC 29425.
Obesity (Silver Spring). 2007 Nov;15 Suppl 1(Suppl 1):27S-36S. doi: 10.1038/oby.2007.385.
Ecological interventions hold promise for promoting overweight and obesity prevention in worksites. Given the paucity of evaluative research in the hospital worksite setting, considerable formative work is required for successful implementation and evaluation. This paper describes the formative phases of Step Ahead, a site-randomized controlled trial of a multilevel intervention that promotes physical activity and healthy eating in six hospitals in central Massachusetts. The purpose of the formative research phase was to increase the feasibility, effectiveness, and likelihood of sustainability of the intervention.
The Step Ahead ecological intervention approach targets change at the organization, interpersonal work environment, and individual levels. The intervention was developed using fundamental steps of intervention mapping and important tenets of participatory research. Formative research methods were used to engage leadership support and assistance and to develop an intervention plan that is both theoretically and practically grounded. This report uses observational data, program minutes and reports, and process tracking data.
Leadership involvement (key informant interviews and advisory boards), employee focus groups and advisory boards, and quantitative environmental assessments cultivated participation and support. Determining multiple foci of change and designing measurable objectives and generic assessment tools to document progress are complex challenges encountered in planning phases.
Multilevel trials in diverse organizations require flexibility and balance of theory application and practice-based perspectives to affect impact and outcome objectives. Formative research is an essential component.
生态干预有望促进工作场所的超重和肥胖预防。鉴于医院工作场所环境中评估性研究较少,要成功实施和评估就需要开展大量的前期筹备工作。本文描述了“向前一步”(Step Ahead)的前期筹备阶段,这是一项在马萨诸塞州中部六家医院进行的多层次干预的现场随机对照试验,该干预旨在促进身体活动和健康饮食。前期筹备研究阶段的目的是提高干预措施的可行性、有效性和可持续性的可能性。
“向前一步”生态干预方法旨在在组织、人际工作环境和个人层面实现变革。该干预措施是利用干预映射的基本步骤和参与式研究的重要原则制定的。前期筹备研究方法用于争取领导层的支持与协助,并制定一个既有理论依据又有实践基础的干预计划。本报告使用观察数据、项目会议记录和报告以及过程跟踪数据。
领导层的参与(关键信息访谈和咨询委员会)、员工焦点小组和咨询委员会以及定量环境评估促进了参与和支持。确定多个变革重点并设计可衡量的目标以及通用评估工具以记录进展情况,是规划阶段遇到的复杂挑战。
在不同组织中进行的多层次试验需要灵活性以及理论应用和基于实践的观点之间的平衡,以实现影响和成果目标。前期筹备研究是一个重要组成部分。