McEvoy Peter M, Shand Fiona
Clinical Research Unit for Anxiety and Depression, School of Psychiatry at St Vincent's Hospital, University of New South Wales, Darlinghurst, Sydney, NSW, Australia.
J Anxiety Disord. 2008 Aug;22(6):1087-98. doi: 10.1016/j.janxdis.2007.11.007. Epub 2007 Nov 21.
This study examined the impact of concurrent substance use disorders (SUDs) on outcomes for psychotherapy targeting anxiety disorders. Study 1 (N=484) sought to determine the prevalence of SUDs in a sample referred to a community anxiety disorders clinic, as well as the impact of comorbid SUDs on outcomes for a subsample (n=200) completing cognitive behavior therapy (CBT). Around one-quarter (22-29%) of patients with one or two anxiety disorders met criteria for at least one SUD, but this rate was substantially higher (46%) for patients with three anxiety disorders. Concurrent SUDs were associated with higher levels of anxiety but not depression or stress, compared to those without a SUD. However, concurrent SUDs did not moderate treatment outcomes. Study 2 (N=103) focused on the impact of alcohol use on diagnosis-specific symptom measures and generic measures of distress and disability, following a course of CBT for panic disorder or social phobia. Pre-treatment alcohol use did not predict changes in panic symptoms, performance anxiety, distress, or disability, but it did predict changes in social interaction anxiety. Problem drinking per se did not have any predictive utility in terms of treatment outcome. These findings suggest that clinicians treating patients for a primary anxiety disorder and concurrent SUD can be relatively optimistic about treatment outcomes.
本研究考察了并发物质使用障碍(SUDs)对针对焦虑症的心理治疗效果的影响。研究1(N = 484)旨在确定转至社区焦虑症诊所的样本中SUDs的患病率,以及并发SUDs对完成认知行为疗法(CBT)的子样本(n = 200)治疗效果的影响。患有一种或两种焦虑症的患者中,约四分之一(22 - 29%)符合至少一种SUDs的标准,但患有三种焦虑症的患者这一比例显著更高(46%)。与没有SUDs的患者相比,并发SUDs与更高水平的焦虑相关,但与抑郁或压力无关。然而,并发SUDs并未调节治疗效果。研究2(N = 103)关注在针对惊恐障碍或社交恐惧症进行CBT疗程后,饮酒对特定诊断症状指标以及痛苦和残疾的一般指标的影响。治疗前饮酒并不能预测惊恐症状、表演焦虑、痛苦或残疾的变化,但它确实能预测社交互动焦虑的变化。就治疗效果而言,问题饮酒本身没有任何预测作用。这些发现表明,治疗患有原发性焦虑症和并发SUDs患者的临床医生可以对治疗效果相对乐观。