Kim Heejung S
University of California, Santa Barbara, CA 93106-9660, USA.
J Pers Soc Psychol. 2008 Jan;94(1):32-47. doi: 10.1037/0022-3514.94.1.32.
The present research investigated cultural differences in the psychological and biological effects of verbalization of thoughts. Three studies tested how verbalization of thoughts requires a different amount of effort for people from cultures with different assumptions about speech and examined implications for the cognitive performance and stress hormone response to the task. The results showed that verbalization impaired East Asians/East Asian Americans' performance when the task was difficult but not when the task was easy, whereas the effect of verbalization on European Americans' performance was neutral or positive regardless of task difficulty. Moreover, verbalization decreased the level of cortisol response to the task among European Americans but not among East Asian Americans. The results demonstrate how the same act that is intended to create the same psychological experience could inadvertently lead to systematically different psychological experiences for people from different cultures.
本研究调查了思想言语化在心理和生物学效应方面的文化差异。三项研究测试了对于来自对言语有不同假设的文化背景的人而言,思想言语化需要付出的努力程度有何不同,并考察了其对任务认知表现和应激激素反应的影响。结果表明,当任务困难时,言语化会损害东亚人/华裔美国人的表现,但任务简单时则不会;而无论任务难度如何,言语化对欧裔美国人表现的影响是中性或积极的。此外,言语化降低了欧裔美国人对应激任务的皮质醇反应水平,但华裔美国人却没有。这些结果表明,旨在创造相同心理体验的同一行为,可能会无意中导致来自不同文化背景的人产生系统性的不同心理体验。