Mugisha John Frank, Reynolds Heidi
Regional Centre for Quality of Health Care, Makerere University Institute of Public Health, Kampala, Uganda.
J Fam Plann Reprod Health Care. 2008 Jan;34(1):37-41. doi: 10.1783/147118908783332230.
Provider perspectives on the quality of family planning services have been overlooked in quality of care research and interventions. This qualitative study was carried out in four districts in Uganda, a country where lack of access to quality family planning services remains a challenge. Using four focus group discussions, 16 provider in-depth interviews and nine manager in-depth interviews, this study documented providers' perceptions of quality of care and of barriers to quality services at the organisational and societal levels. To guide study development, analysis and interpretation, the authors relied on an ecological framework where providers' abilities are shaped by the larger organisational and societal environments in which providers live and work.
Providers felt that organisational factors, such as supply availability, workload and their own knowledge and skills, affected their abilities to offer quality care. At the same time, providers were challenged by societal factors such as male partner participation, financial constraints, misconceptions and leadership support. While making changes to the elements of quality care that clients experience is important, it is not sufficient in view of the organisational and social barriers.
Across the different levels of the ecological framework, providers face barriers to providing quality family planning services that are synergistic. Solutions to improve quality of care must address also limitations at the organisational and societal levels since efforts to overcome a particular constraint are less likely to be successful if this interdependence is not taken into account.
在医疗服务质量研究及干预措施中,医疗服务提供者对计划生育服务质量的看法一直被忽视。本定性研究在乌干达的四个地区开展,在该国,难以获得高质量计划生育服务仍是一项挑战。通过四次焦点小组讨论、16次提供者深度访谈和9次管理者深度访谈,本研究记录了提供者对医疗服务质量以及组织和社会层面优质服务障碍的看法。为指导研究的开展、分析和解读,作者依据一个生态框架,在该框架中,提供者的能力受到其生活和工作的更大组织及社会环境的影响。
提供者认为,诸如供应可用性、工作量以及他们自身的知识和技能等组织因素会影响他们提供优质医疗服务的能力。与此同时,提供者还面临着诸如男性伴侣参与度、经济限制、误解和领导支持等社会因素的挑战。虽然改变客户所体验的优质医疗服务要素很重要,但鉴于组织和社会障碍,这还不够。
在生态框架的不同层面上,提供者在提供优质计划生育服务时面临着相互协同的障碍。提高医疗服务质量的解决方案还必须解决组织和社会层面的限制,因为如果不考虑这种相互依存关系,克服特定制约因素的努力不太可能成功。