Kleijnen J, Knipschild P
Department of Epidemiology/Health Care Research, University of Limburg, The Netherlands.
Biol Psychiatry. 1991 May 1;29(9):931-41. doi: 10.1016/0006-3223(91)90060-y.
Fifty-three controlled trials of the effects of niacin, vitamin B6, and multivitamins on mental functions are reviewed. The results are interpreted with emphasis on the methodological quality of the trials. It turns out that virtually all trials show serious short-comings: in the number of participants, the presentation of baseline characteristics and outcomes, and the description of changes in concomitant treatments. Only in autistic children are some positive results are found with very high dosages of vitamin B6 combined with magnesium, but further evidence is needed before more definitive conclusions can be drawn. For many other indications (hyperactive children, children with Down's syndrome, IQ changes in healthy schoolchildren, schizophrenia, psychological functions in healthy adults and geriatric patients) there is no adequate support from controlled trials in favor of vitamin supplementation.
本文综述了53项关于烟酸、维生素B6和多种维生素对心理功能影响的对照试验。结果解读着重于试验的方法学质量。事实证明,几乎所有试验都存在严重缺陷:在参与者数量、基线特征和结果呈现以及伴随治疗变化的描述方面。仅在自闭症儿童中,发现高剂量维生素B6与镁联合使用有一些积极结果,但在得出更明确结论之前还需要进一步证据。对于许多其他适应症(多动症儿童、唐氏综合征儿童、健康学童的智商变化、精神分裂症、健康成年人和老年患者的心理功能),对照试验没有充分支持补充维生素。