Tan Li Hai, Chan Alice H D, Kay Paul, Khong Pek-Lan, Yip Lawrance K C, Luke Kang-Kwong
Department of Linguistics, State Key Laboratory of Brain and Cognitive Sciences, and Department of Diagnostic Radiology, University of Hong Kong, Pokfulam Road, Hong Kong.
Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 2008 Mar 11;105(10):4004-9. doi: 10.1073/pnas.0800055105. Epub 2008 Mar 3.
Well over half a century ago, Benjamin Lee Whorf [Carroll JB (1956) Language, Thought, and Reality: Selected Writings of Benjamin Lee Whorf (MIT Press, Cambridge, MA)] proposed that language affects perception and thought and is used to segment nature, a hypothesis that has since been tested by linguistic and behavioral studies. Although clear Whorfian effects have been found, it has not yet been demonstrated that language influences brain activity associated with perception and/or immediate postperceptual processes (referred hereafter as "perceptual decision"). Here, by using functional magnetic resonance imaging, we show that brain regions mediating language processes participate in neural networks activated by perceptual decision. When subjects performed a perceptual discrimination task on easy-to-name and hard-to-name colored squares, largely overlapping cortical regions were identified, which included areas of the occipital cortex critical for color vision and regions in the bilateral frontal gyrus. Crucially, however, in comparison with hard-to-name colored squares, perceptual discrimination of easy-to-name colors evoked stronger activation in the left posterior superior temporal gyrus and inferior parietal lobule, two regions responsible for word-finding processes, as demonstrated by a localizer experiment that uses an explicit color patch naming task. This finding suggests that the language-processing areas of the brain are directly involved in visual perceptual decision, thus providing neuroimaging support for the Whorf hypothesis.
半个多世纪以前,本杰明·李·沃尔夫[卡罗尔·J·B(1956年)《语言、思维与现实:本杰明·李·沃尔夫选集》(麻省理工学院出版社,马萨诸塞州剑桥)]提出,语言会影响感知和思维,并用于对自然进行划分,自那以后,这一假设已通过语言学和行为学研究得到验证。尽管已经发现了明显的沃尔夫效应,但尚未证明语言会影响与感知和/或感知后即刻过程(以下简称“感知决策”)相关的大脑活动。在此,我们通过功能磁共振成像表明,介导语言过程的脑区参与了由感知决策激活的神经网络。当受试者对易于命名和难以命名的彩色方块执行感知辨别任务时,识别出了大量重叠的皮质区域,其中包括对颜色视觉至关重要的枕叶皮质区域以及双侧额回中的区域。然而,至关重要的是,与难以命名的彩色方块相比,对易于命名颜色的感知辨别在左后颞上回和下顶叶小叶中引发了更强的激活,这两个区域负责词汇查找过程,正如一项使用明确的色块命名任务的定位实验所证明的那样。这一发现表明,大脑的语言处理区域直接参与视觉感知决策,从而为沃尔夫假设提供了神经影像学支持。