Carr Vaughan J, Lewin Terry J, Sly Ketrina A, Conrad Agatha M, Tirupati Srinivasan, Cohen Martin, Ward Philip B, Coombs Tim
Centre for Brain and Mental Health Research, University of Newcastle, Callaghan, NSW, Australia.
Aust N Z J Psychiatry. 2008 Apr;42(4):267-82. doi: 10.1080/00048670701881520.
This paper reports findings from a multicentre service evaluation project conducted in acute psychiatric inpatient units in NSW, Australia. Overall rates of aggression, absconding and early readmission are reported, as well as length-of-stay profiles and associations between these outcomes and selected sociodemographic and clinical characteristics routinely collected by health services.
Data from the 11 participating units were collected for a 12month period from multiple sources, including electronic medical records, routine clinical modules, incident forms, and shift based project-specific logs. For the current analyses, two admission-level datasets were used, comprising aggregated patient-level events (n=3242 admissions) and basic sociodemographic, clinical, admission and discharge information (n=5546 admissions by 3877 patients).
The participating units were under considerable strain: 23.3% of admissions were high acuity; 60.4% had previous hospital stays; 47.6% were involuntary; 25-30% involved adverse incidents; bed occupancy averaged 88.4%; median length of stay was 8 days (mean=14.59 days); and 17.4% had a subsequent early readmission. Reportable aggressive incidents (11.2% of admissions) were intermittent (averaging 0.55 incidents per month per occupied bed) and associated with younger age, personality disorder, less serious aggression, longer periods of hospitalization, and subsequent early readmission. Less serious aggressive incidents (15.0% of admissions) were maximal in the first 24h (averaging 3.73 incidents per month per occupied bed) and associated with younger age, involuntary status, bipolar and personality disorders, the absence of depression, and longer hospital stays. Absconding (15.7% of admissions) peaked in the second week following admission and was associated with drug and alcohol disorder, younger age, and longer periods of hospitalization.
By examining relationships between a core set of risk factors and multiple short-term outcomes, we were able to identify several important patterns, which were suggestive of the need for a multi-level approach to intervention, shifting from a risk management focus during the early phase of hospitalization to a more targeted, therapeutic approach during the later phase. But the latter approach may not be achievable under current circumstances with existing resources.
本文报告了在澳大利亚新南威尔士州急性精神科住院病房开展的一项多中心服务评估项目的结果。报告了攻击行为、擅自离院和早期再入院的总体发生率,以及住院时间概况,以及这些结果与卫生服务机构常规收集的选定社会人口学和临床特征之间的关联。
从11个参与单位收集了为期12个月的数据,数据来源包括电子病历、常规临床模块、事件表格以及基于班次的特定项目日志。对于当前分析,使用了两个入院级数据集,包括汇总的患者级事件(3242例入院)和基本社会人口学、临床、入院和出院信息(3877名患者的5546例入院)。
参与单位面临相当大的压力:23.3%的入院患者病情严重;60.4%的患者曾住院治疗;47.6%的入院属于非自愿性;25%-30%的入院涉及不良事件;床位占用率平均为88.4%;住院时间中位数为8天(平均=14.59天);17.4%的患者随后早期再入院。可报告的攻击事件(占入院患者的11.2%)具有间歇性(每张占用床位每月平均0.55起事件),且与年龄较小、人格障碍、攻击行为不太严重、住院时间较长以及随后的早期再入院有关。不太严重的攻击事件(占入院患者的15.0%)在最初24小时内最多(每张占用床位每月平均3.73起事件),且与年龄较小、非自愿状态、双相情感障碍和人格障碍、无抑郁症以及住院时间较长有关。擅自离院(占入院患者的15.7%)在入院后第二周达到高峰,且与药物和酒精障碍、年龄较小以及住院时间较长有关。
通过研究一组核心风险因素与多个短期结果之间的关系,我们能够识别出几种重要模式,这表明需要采取多层次干预方法,从住院早期的风险管理重点转向后期更有针对性的治疗方法。但在当前情况下,利用现有资源可能无法实现后一种方法。