Ethier Vincent, Zee David S, Shadmehr Reza
Department of Biomedical Engineering, Johns Hopkins School of Medicine, 720 Rutland Avenue, Baltimore, MD 21205, USA.
J Neurophysiol. 2008 May;99(5):2577-83. doi: 10.1152/jn.00015.2008. Epub 2008 Mar 19.
It is possible that motor adaptation in timescales of minutes is supported by two distinct processes: one process that learns slowly from error but has strong retention, and another that learns rapidly from error but has poor retention. This two-state model makes the prediction that if a period of adaptation is followed by a period of reverse-adaptation, then in the subsequent period in which errors are clamped to zero (error-clamp trials) there will be a spontaneous recovery, i.e., a rebound of behavior toward the initial level of adaptation. Here we tested and confirmed this prediction during double-step, on-axis, saccade adaptation. When people adapted their saccadic gain to a magnitude other than one (adaptation) and then the gain was rapidly reversed back to one (reverse-adaptation), in the subsequent error-clamp trials (visual target placed on the fovea after the saccade) the gain reverted toward the initially adapted value and then gradually reverted toward normal. We estimated that the fast system was about 20-fold more sensitive to error than the slow system, but had a time constant of 28 s, whereas the slow system had a time constant of nearly 8 min. Therefore short-term adaptive mechanisms that maintain accuracy of saccades rely on a memory system that has characteristics of a multistate process with a logarithmic distribution of timescales.
一个过程从误差中学习缓慢但具有较强的记忆保持能力,另一个过程从误差中学习迅速但记忆保持能力较差。这种双状态模型预测,如果一段适应期之后接着是一段反向适应期,那么在随后误差被钳制为零的时期(误差钳制试验)将会有自发恢复,即行为朝着初始适应水平反弹。在这里,我们在双步、轴向扫视适应过程中测试并证实了这一预测。当人们将扫视增益调整到不同于1的幅度(适应),然后增益迅速反向变回1(反向适应)时,在随后的误差钳制试验(扫视后将视觉目标置于中央凹)中,增益朝着最初适应的值恢复,然后逐渐恢复到正常。我们估计,快速系统对误差的敏感度比慢速系统高约20倍,但时间常数为28秒,而慢速系统的时间常数接近8分钟。因此,维持扫视准确性的短期适应机制依赖于一个具有多状态过程特征且时间尺度呈对数分布的记忆系统。