Green A L, Lombard J E, Garber L P, Wagner B A, Hill G W
USDA:APHIS:VS, Centers for Epidemiology and Animal Health, 2150 Centre Ave., Bldg. B, Fort Collins, CO 80526-8117, USA.
J Dairy Sci. 2008 Jun;91(6):2275-83. doi: 10.3168/jds.2007-0869.
The primary objective of this study was to compare characteristics of US dairy operations that had one or more nonambulatory cows (unable to rise for any period of time) (cases) with operations that had no nonambulatory cows (controls) during 2004. A secondary objective was to describe factors associated with recovery of the last nonambulatory cow on the operation during 2004. Case dairy operations (n = 1,822) more often fed a total mixed ration [odds ratio (OR) = 2.0; confidence interval (CI): 1.1-3.4], produced more than 9,090 kg of milk (OR = 2.8; CI: 1.8-4.5), and were more likely to be of medium to large herd size (100 or more head of adult cows, OR = 3.7; CI: 2.2-6.2) compared with control dairies (n = 151). Compared with operations where the predominant flooring surface on which lactating cows stood or walked in winter was pasture, operations where pasture was not the predominant surface were at increased risk of having nonambulatory cows (OR = 4.7; CI: 2.2-10.2). Cows nonambulatory for less than 24 h were more likely to recover compared with cows nonambulatory for 24 h or more (OR = 3.0; CI: 2.0-4.4). Cows that received calcium, phosphorus, or potassium while non-ambulatory were more likely to recover (OR = 3.6; CI: 2.1-6.1) than cattle that did not receive these treatments. Cattle that were not repositioned periodically were more likely to recover (OR = 2.1; CI: 1.4-3.1), as were cattle that were not treated by a veterinarian before becoming nonambulatory (OR = 1.9; CI: 1.1-3.3). These findings are consistent with prolonged recumbency and prior history of health issues, respectively. Nonambulatory cattle with hypocalcemia were more likely to recover (OR = 6.0; CI: 3.4-10.7) compared with nonambulatory cows with all other causes of a nonambulatory condition (analyzed collectively as a single variable but including cancer, clinical mastitis, digestive conditions, metabolic imbalances, neurological problems, respiratory disease, other, unknown). The results of this study reveal that the majority of US dairy operations have at least one nonambulatory dairy cow over the course of a year. Additionally, individual animal factors associated with being nonambulatory may lead to improved identification and treatment of animals that are nonambulatory for a prolonged period. From the perspective of recovery, considering euthanasia is appropriate for cows that have been nonambulatory for more than 24 h.
本研究的主要目的是比较2004年美国有一头或多头非能走动奶牛(在任何时间段都无法站立)的奶牛场(病例组)与没有非能走动奶牛的奶牛场(对照组)的特征。次要目的是描述与2004年该奶牛场最后一头非能走动奶牛恢复相关的因素。与对照组奶牛场(n = 151)相比,病例组奶牛场(n = 1,822)更常采用全混合日粮饲喂[优势比(OR)= 2.0;置信区间(CI):1.1 - 3.4],产奶量超过9,090千克(OR = 2.8;CI:1.8 - 4.5),且更有可能是中型至大型牛群规模(100头或更多成年母牛,OR = 3.7;CI:2.2 - 6.2)。与冬季泌乳奶牛站立或行走的主要地面为牧场的奶牛场相比,主要地面不是牧场的奶牛场出现非能走动奶牛的风险增加(OR = 4.7;CI:2.2 - 10.2)。与非能走动24小时及以上的奶牛相比,非能走动时间少于24小时的奶牛更有可能恢复(OR = 3.0;CI:2.0 - 4.4)。非能走动时接受钙、磷或钾治疗的奶牛比未接受这些治疗的奶牛更有可能恢复(OR = 3.6;CI:2.1 - 6.1)。不定期重新安置的奶牛更有可能恢复(OR = 2.1;CI:1.4 - 3.1),在变为非能走动之前未接受兽医治疗的奶牛也是如此(OR = 1.9;CI:1.1 - .3)。这些发现分别与长期躺卧和健康问题的既往史一致。与因所有其他非能走动原因(作为一个单一变量综合分析,但包括癌症、临床乳腺炎、消化系统疾病、代谢失衡、神经问题、呼吸系统疾病、其他、不明原因)导致非能走动的奶牛相比,患有低钙血症的非能走动奶牛更有可能恢复(OR = 6.0;CI:3.4 - 10.7)。本研究结果表明,美国大多数奶牛场在一年中至少有一头非能走动的奶牛。此外,与非能走动相关的个体动物因素可能有助于改进对长期非能走动动物的识别和治疗。从恢复的角度来看,对于非能走动超过24小时的奶牛,考虑实施安乐死是合适的。