Schmidt Barbara, Roberts Robin, Millar David, Kirpalani Haresh
Department of Pediatrics, Children's Hospital of Philadelphia and the University of Pennsylvania, Philadelphia, Pa. 19104, USA.
Neonatology. 2008;93(4):284-7. doi: 10.1159/000121453. Epub 2008 Jun 5.
Corticosteroids, intramuscular vitamin A and caffeine reduce the risk of bronchopulmonary dysplasia (BPD) in very-low-birth-weight infants. We compared the size of the beneficial drug effects on BPD and evaluated long-term drug safety by estimating the number needed to treat (NNT) and the number needed to harm (NNH) for the outcome of cerebral palsy (CP). When given prophylactically during the first 4 days of life, corticosteroids increase the risk of CP (NNH 22; 95% CI: 12-133). When prescribed between days 7 and 14, corticosteroids reduce the 28-day mortality rate in addition to reducing BPD. Their effect on CP remains uncertain: the limited data available are consistent with a best-case scenario (NNT 15) and a worst-case scenario (NNH 14). Although repeated intramuscular injections of vitamin A during the 1st month of life reduce BPD (NNT 12; 95% CI: 6-94), estimates for CP range from an NNT of 11 to an NNH of 33. Early use of caffeine reduces both BPD and CP. The NNT for BPD is 10 (95% CI: 7-16), while the NNT for CP is 34 (95% CI: 20-132). We conclude that caffeine is the drug of choice for the prevention of BPD in very-low-birth-weight infants. Corticosteroids should be avoided during the first few days of life. However, when given during the 2nd week of life to infants at high risk of BPD corticosteroids may have important short- and long-term benefits. These should be urgently confirmed or refuted in well-designed controlled trials.
皮质类固醇、肌肉注射维生素A和咖啡因可降低极低出生体重儿患支气管肺发育不良(BPD)的风险。我们比较了这些药物对BPD的有益作用大小,并通过估计治疗脑瘫(CP)结局所需的治疗人数(NNT)和伤害人数(NNH)来评估长期药物安全性。在出生后的前4天预防性使用皮质类固醇会增加患CP的风险(NNH 22;95%置信区间:12 - 133)。在第7天至第14天使用时,皮质类固醇除了降低BPD外,还可降低28天死亡率。其对CP的影响仍不确定:现有有限数据与最佳情况(NNT 15)和最坏情况(NNH 14)一致。尽管在出生后第1个月内重复肌肉注射维生素A可降低BPD(NNT 12;95%置信区间:6 - 94),但对CP的估计范围从NNT为11到NNH为33。早期使用咖啡因可降低BPD和CP。BPD的NNT为10(95%置信区间:7 - 16),而CP的NNT为34(95%置信区间:20 - 132)。我们得出结论,咖啡因是预防极低出生体重儿BPD的首选药物。在出生后的头几天应避免使用皮质类固醇。然而,在出生后第2周给有BPD高风险的婴儿使用皮质类固醇可能会有重要的短期和长期益处。这些应在精心设计的对照试验中尽快得到证实或反驳。