Svensson E, Waling K, Häger-Ross C
Department of Community Medicine and Rehabilitation, Section for Physiotherapy, Umeå University, Sweden.
Acta Paediatr. 2008 Sep;97(9):1226-31. doi: 10.1111/j.1651-2227.2008.00895.x. Epub 2008 Jun 6.
To examine the reliability of peak and sustained grip strength in children using the Grippit. We compared the reliability of one trial, the best and mean of three trials and the reliability within 6-, 10- and 14-year-old groups.
Test-retest study.
Grip strength with the Grippit instrument was evaluated at two test occasions in 58 children. Intraclass correlation coefficient 2.1 (ICC), standard error of measurement (SEM) also expressed as a percentage value (SEM%), coefficient of repeatability and coefficient of variation were calculated.
The test-retest reliability was good for both peak and sustained grip strength. The mean and best of three trials were equally reliable. Peak grip strength best of three trials, for example, was more reliable for the 6-year-olds (ICC 0.96, SEM% 6.3) and 14-year-olds (ICC 0.96, SEM% 5.2) compared to the 10-year-olds (ICC 0.78, SEM% 12.5). For peak grip strength in the whole sample, there was a systematic bias with better performance at the second measurement.
Grip strength assessment in children with Grippit results in good relative and absolute reliability for peak and sustained grip strength. We recommend that three test trials are used. The mean of and the best of three trials are comparable.
使用Grippit评估儿童峰值握力和持续握力的可靠性。我们比较了一次试验、三次试验的最佳值和平均值的可靠性,以及6岁、10岁和14岁年龄组内的可靠性。
重测研究。
在两个测试场合对58名儿童使用Grippit仪器评估握力。计算组内相关系数2.1(ICC)、测量标准误差(SEM)也表示为百分比值(SEM%)、重复性系数和变异系数。
峰值握力和持续握力的重测可靠性均良好。三次试验的平均值和最佳值同样可靠。例如,与10岁儿童(ICC 0.78,SEM% 12.5)相比,三次试验中峰值握力最佳值在6岁儿童(ICC 0.96,SEM% 6.3)和14岁儿童(ICC 0.96,SEM% 5.2)中更可靠。对于整个样本的峰值握力,第二次测量时表现更好存在系统偏差。
使用Grippit评估儿童握力可得出峰值握力和持续握力良好的相对和绝对可靠性。我们建议进行三次测试试验。三次试验的平均值和最佳值具有可比性。