Budgeon Mark K, Latash Mark L, Zatsiorsky Vladimir M
Department of Kinesiology, The Pennsylvania State University, University Park, PA, USA.
Exp Brain Res. 2008 Aug;189(3):345-59. doi: 10.1007/s00221-008-1430-9. Epub 2008 Jun 14.
We explored adjustments in multi-digit coordinated action on a hand-held object with finger addition and removal. The subjects (n = 7) kept a vertically oriented handle at rest using a prismatic grasp as if holding a glass of liquid and then either added one finger to the grasp, the index (I) or little (L) finger, or removed one finger. Three external torques were applied on the apparatus: clockwise, counterclockwise, and no torque. The individual digit forces and moments were recorded with six-component sensors. The change in grasping force, normal force of the thumb and virtual finger (VF, an imagined finger that generates the same mechanical effect as all fingers together), depended on the function of the manipulated finger, i.e. on whether the finger resisted external torque (torque agonist) or assisted it (torque antagonist). There was a significant increase of the grasping force when an antagonist was added or when an agonist was removed. These force increases were not necessary for slipping prevention: the normal forces prior to the manipulation were large enough to prevent slipping. All other finger manipulations exhibited no significant change in the grip force, except for the antagonist removal during the supination efforts (after removing the I finger the grasping force decreased). In contrast, the changes in the tangential force of the thumb depended on the manipulated finger, not on the finger function with respect to external torque. There was a significant thumb tangential force increase when the I finger was added or when the L finger was removed; opposite changes were seen when the L finger was added or the I finger was removed. The changes of the virtual finger (VF) tangential force were equal and opposite to the thumb tangential force alterations; these opposite changes caused changes in the moments, these forces generated. The changes in the moments of the tangential forces were counterbalanced by the opposite changes in the moments of normal forces such that the total moment remained constant and the handle orientation was maintained. At the level of individual finger (IF) forces two strategies of error compensation were found: (a) local error compensation--the opposite action of the neighboring finger, i.e. force decrease in response to a force increase (finger addition), and vice versa and (b) distant error compensation--similar action by a finger that is a torque antagonist to the manipulated finger. During the transient periods, the changes in the thumb and VF forces were simultaneous and equal in magnitude. The normal forces increased or decreased concurrently while the changes in the tangential forces were opposite in direction. The data support the existence of chain effects in the digit force adjustments to finger addition or removal. We conclude that the digit force adjustments during the object manipulation are controlled mainly in a feed-forward manner. The obtained data agree with the principle of superposition reported previously. The findings agree with earlier reports on the limited ability of CNS to organize synergies at two levels of a control hierarchy simultaneously.
我们研究了在手持物体上进行多指协同动作时,手指添加和移除所带来的调整。受试者(n = 7)以棱柱形抓握方式使垂直放置的手柄保持静止,就像拿着一杯液体一样,然后要么在抓握中添加一根手指,食指(I)或小指(L),要么移除一根手指。在装置上施加了三种外部扭矩:顺时针、逆时针和无扭矩。通过六分量传感器记录各个手指的力和力矩。抓握力、拇指和虚拟手指(VF,一根想象中的手指,其产生的机械效果与所有手指共同产生的效果相同)的法向力的变化,取决于被操作手指的功能,即该手指是抵抗外部扭矩(扭矩 agonist)还是辅助外部扭矩(扭矩 antagonist)。当添加一个 antagonist 或移除一个 agonist 时,抓握力会显著增加。这些力的增加对于防止滑动并非必要:操作前的法向力足够大以防止滑动。除了在旋前动作中移除 antagonist 时(移除食指后抓握力下降),所有其他手指操作在握力上均未表现出显著变化。相比之下,拇指切向力的变化取决于被操作手指,而非相对于外部扭矩的手指功能。当添加食指或移除小指时,拇指切向力显著增加;当添加小指或移除食指时,则出现相反的变化。虚拟手指(VF)切向力的变化与拇指切向力的变化大小相等、方向相反;这些相反的变化导致了这些力所产生的力矩的变化。切向力力矩的变化被法向力力矩的相反变化所抵消,从而使总力矩保持恒定,手柄方向得以维持。在单个手指(IF)力的层面上,发现了两种误差补偿策略:(a)局部误差补偿——相邻手指的相反动作,即响应于力的增加(手指添加)而力减小,反之亦然;(b)远距离误差补偿——与被操作手指为扭矩 antagonist 的手指的类似动作。在过渡期间,拇指和 VF 力的变化是同时发生的,且大小相等。法向力同时增加或减小,而切向力的变化方向相反。这些数据支持在手指添加或移除时,手指力调整中存在连锁效应。我们得出结论,物体操作过程中的手指力调整主要以前馈方式进行控制。所获得的数据与先前报道的叠加原理相符。这些发现与早期关于中枢神经系统在控制层次的两个层面上同时组织协同作用能力有限的报道一致。