Clatney Lisa, Macdonald Heather, Shah Syed M
Health Quality Council, 241-111 Research Dr, Saskatoon, SK S7N 3R2.
Can Fam Physician. 2008 Jun;54(6):884-9.
To assess family physicians' interactions with mental health professionals (MHPs), their satisfaction with the delivery of mental health care in primary health care settings, and their perceptions of areas for improvement.
Mailed survey.
Province of Saskatchewan.
All FPs in Saskatchewan (N = 816) were invited to participate in the study; 31 were later determined to be ineligible because they were specialist physicians, were no longer practising regularly, or could not be located.
Family physicians' self-reported satisfaction with and interest in mental health care; perceived strengths and areas for improvement in the quality of mental health care delivery in primary health care settings.
The response rate was 48%, with 375 FPs completing the survey. More than half of the responding FPs (56%) reported seeing 11 or more patients with mental health problems per week. Although 83% of responding FPs were interested or very interested in identifying or treating mental health problems, fewer than half (46%) reported being satisfied with the mental health care they were able to deliver. Family physician satisfaction was significantly higher among those with on-site MHPs (P < .05) and those who saw fewer patients with mental health problems per week (P < .01). The most common mode of interaction that FPs reported having with MHPs was through written correspondence; somewhat less common were telephone and face-to-face interactions. The most common strength FPs identified in their provision of mental health care was having access to psychiatrists, community mental health nurses, and other MHPs. The most common area for improvement in primary mental health care also fell under the category of access. Specifically, FPs felt access to psychiatrists needed to be improved.
Mental health problems are very common in primary care. Most FPs are very interested in the detection and treatment of mental health problems. Despite this high level of interest, however, FPs are generally dissatisfied with the quality of mental health care they are able to provide. Access to MHPs was cited as a critical element in improving the delivery of mental health services in primary care.
评估家庭医生与心理健康专业人员(MHP)的互动情况、他们对初级卫生保健机构中精神卫生保健服务的满意度以及他们对改进领域的看法。
邮寄调查。
萨斯喀彻温省。
邀请了萨斯喀彻温省的所有家庭医生(N = 816)参与研究;后来确定31人不符合条件,因为他们是专科医生、不再定期执业或无法找到。
家庭医生自我报告的对精神卫生保健的满意度和兴趣;对初级卫生保健机构中精神卫生保健服务质量的感知优势和改进领域。
回复率为48%,有375名家庭医生完成了调查。超过一半(56%)的回复家庭医生报告每周诊治11名或更多有心理健康问题的患者。尽管83%的回复家庭医生对识别或治疗心理健康问题感兴趣或非常感兴趣,但不到一半(46%)的人报告对他们能够提供的精神卫生保健服务感到满意。在有现场心理健康专业人员的家庭医生中(P < .05)以及每周诊治心理健康问题患者较少的家庭医生中(P < .01),家庭医生的满意度明显更高。家庭医生报告与心理健康专业人员最常见的互动方式是通过书面通信;电话和面对面互动则不太常见。家庭医生在提供精神卫生保健服务中确定的最常见优势是能够接触到精神科医生、社区精神卫生护士和其他心理健康专业人员。初级精神卫生保健最常见的改进领域也属于可及性范畴。具体而言,家庭医生认为接触精神科医生的机会需要改善。
心理健康问题在初级保健中非常普遍。大多数家庭医生对心理健康问题的检测和治疗非常感兴趣。然而,尽管兴趣浓厚,但家庭医生总体上对他们能够提供的精神卫生保健服务质量不满意。获得心理健康专业人员的服务被认为是改善初级保健中精神卫生服务提供的关键因素。