Ahmed Adel Refaat
Department of Orthopedic Surgery, Alexandria University, PO 4, Lambrozo, Alexandria, Egypt.
Arch Orthop Trauma Surg. 2009 Apr;129(4):483-7. doi: 10.1007/s00402-008-0674-y. Epub 2008 Jun 21.
Local recurrence after resection of sacral chordoma is a challenging problem for the orthopedic oncologists. That is why analysis of its margins of safety is of outmost importance.
Eighteen cases of sacral chordoma were retrospectively reviewed. All the patients were followed for determination of their status clinically and radiographically. The surgical margins for every resected tumor were evaluated proximally, ventrally, and at the postero-lateral aspect of the sacrum.
Ventrally, the surgical margins were seven marginal and ten wide margins. Proximally, there were three marginal, nine wide and five curative margins. Postero-laterally, there were one intra-lesional, one marginal, 12 wide and three curative margins. Local recurrence encountered postero-laterally in six cases with five wide and one intra-lesional margin. On the other hand, no local recurrence was disclosed ventrally or proximally despite marginal resections were employed to the ventral resection in seven and proximally in three cases. With a mean follow-up of 11 years, six patients died of their disease, and 12 patients were alive. The 5-, 10- and 15-year survival rates were 81, 70, and 33%, respectively.
The appropriate surgical margin for complete removal of the chordoma differs according to the location of the tumor and tissues involved. Marginal margin ventrally and wide margin proximally are sufficient while postero-laterally including the gluteus maximus muscles a curative or radical margin seems to be the appropriate surgical margin to prevent tumor recurrence.
骶骨脊索瘤切除术后的局部复发是骨科肿瘤学家面临的一个具有挑战性的问题。这就是为什么分析其安全切缘至关重要。
回顾性分析18例骶骨脊索瘤病例。对所有患者进行临床和影像学随访以确定其状况。评估每例切除肿瘤在骶骨近端、腹侧和后外侧的手术切缘。
腹侧,手术切缘有7例为边缘性切缘,10例为广泛切缘。近端,有3例边缘性切缘、9例广泛切缘和5例根治性切缘。后外侧,有1例瘤内切缘、1例边缘性切缘、12例广泛切缘和3例根治性切缘。后外侧有6例出现局部复发,其中5例为广泛切缘,1例为瘤内切缘。另一方面,尽管腹侧7例和近端3例采用了边缘性切除,但腹侧和近端均未出现局部复发。平均随访11年,6例患者死于疾病,12例患者存活。5年、10年和15年生存率分别为81%、70%和33%。
根据肿瘤位置和累及组织的不同,完全切除脊索瘤所需的合适手术切缘也不同。腹侧边缘性切缘和近端广泛切缘就足够了,而后外侧包括臀大肌,根治性或根治性切缘似乎是预防肿瘤复发的合适手术切缘。