Weedon-Fekjaer Harald, Lindqvist Bo H, Vatten Lars J, Aalen Odd O, Tretli Steinar
Kreftregisteret, Institute of Population-based Cancer Research, Montebello, N-0310 Oslo, Norway.
J Med Screen. 2008;15(2):83-90. doi: 10.1258/jms.2008.007071.
Mean sojourn time (MST) and screening test sensitivity (STS), is usually estimated by Markov models using incidence data from the first screening round and the interval between screening examinations. However, several screening programmes do not have full registration of cancers submerging after screening, and increased use of opportunistic screening over time can raise questions regarding the quality of interval cancer registration. Methods/settings Based on the earlier used Markov model, formulas for expected number of cases given time since former screening activity was developed. Using questionnaire data for 336,533 women in the Norwegian Breast Cancer Screening Programme (NBCSP), mean square regression estimates of MST and STS were calculated.
In contrast to the previously used method, the new approach gave satisfactory model fit. MST was estimated to 5.6 years for women aged 50-59 years, and 6.9 years for women aged 60-69 years, and STS was estimated to 55% and 60%, respectively. Attempts to add separate parameters for breast cancer incidence without screening, or previous STS, resulted in wide confidence intervals if estimated separately, and non-identifiably if combined.
Previously published results of long MST and low screen test sensitivity were confirmed with the new approach. Questionnaire data on time since previous screening can be used to estimate MST and STS, but the approach is sensitive to relaxing the assumptions regarding the expected breast cancer incidence without screening and constant STS over time.
平均停留时间(MST)和筛查试验敏感性(STS)通常通过马尔可夫模型,利用首轮筛查的发病率数据以及筛查检查之间的间隔来估计。然而,一些筛查项目并未对筛查后隐匿的癌症进行全面登记,并且随着时间推移机会性筛查的使用增加,可能会引发关于间期癌症登记质量的问题。方法/设置基于先前使用的马尔可夫模型,开发了根据自上次筛查活动以来的时间计算预期病例数的公式。利用挪威乳腺癌筛查项目(NBCSP)中336,533名女性的问卷数据,计算了MST和STS的均方回归估计值。
与先前使用的方法不同,新方法给出了令人满意的模型拟合。50 - 59岁女性的MST估计为5.6年,60 - 69岁女性为6.9年,STS分别估计为55%和60%。尝试为未筛查情况下的乳腺癌发病率或先前的STS添加单独参数时,如果单独估计会导致宽置信区间,如果合并则无法识别。
新方法证实了先前发表的MST长和筛查试验敏感性低的结果。关于自上次筛查以来时间的问卷数据可用于估计MST和STS,但该方法对放宽未筛查情况下预期乳腺癌发病率以及随时间恒定的STS的假设较为敏感。