Bett B, Irungu P, Nyamwaro S O, Murilla G, Kitala P, Gathuma J, Randolph T F, McDermott J
Trypanosomiasis Research Centre, Kenya Agricultural Research Institute, P.O. Box 362-00902, Kikuyu, Kenya.
Vet Parasitol. 2008 Aug 17;155(3-4):287-98. doi: 10.1016/j.vetpar.2008.05.028. Epub 2008 May 25.
In an on-farm trial conducted amongst the Maasai pastoralists in Nkuruman and Nkineji areas of Kenya between April 2004 and August 2005 designed to evaluate the effectiveness of a synthetic tsetse repellent technology, we assessed the relationship between tsetse challenge and trypanosomosis incidence in cattle. Six villages were used in each area. Each of these villages had a sentinel cattle herd that was screened for trypanosomosis on monthly basis using buffy coat technique. Animals found infected at each sampling were treated with diminazene aceturate at 7 mg kg(-1) body weight. Treatments administered by the owners over the sampling intervals were recorded as well. Tsetse flies were trapped at the time of sampling using baited stationary traps and apparent tsetse density estimated as flies per trap per day (FTD). A fixed proportion (10%) of the flies was dissected and their infection status determined through microscopy. Blood meals were also collected from some of the flies and their sources identified using enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA). Tsetse challenge was obtained as a product of tsetse density, trypanosome prevalence and the proportion of blood meals obtained from cattle. This variable was transformed using logarithmic function and fitted as an independent factor in a Poisson model that had trypanosomosis incidence in the sentinel cattle as the outcome of interest. The mean trypanosomosis incidence in the sentinel group of cattle was 7.2 and 10.2% in Nkuruman and Nkineji, respectively. Glossina pallidipes was the most prevalent tsetse species in Nkuruman while G. swynnertoni was prevalent in Nkineji. The proportions of tsetse that had mature infections in the respective areas were 0.6 and 4.2%. Most tsetse (28%) sampled in Nkuruman had blood meals from warthogs while most of those sampled in Nkineji (30%) had blood meals from cattle. A statistically significant association between tsetse challenge and trypanosomosis incidence was obtained only in Nkuruman when data was pooled and analyzed at the area but not at the village-level. In the later scenario, lagging tsetse challenge by 1 month improved the strength but not the significance of the association. These findings show that when the spatial unit of analysis in observational studies or on-farm trials is small, for instance a village, it may not be possible to demonstrate a statistically significant association between tsetse challenge and trypanosomosis incidence in livestock so as to effectively control for tsetse challenge.
2004年4月至2005年8月期间,在肯尼亚恩库鲁曼和恩基尼吉地区的马赛牧民中进行了一项农场试验,旨在评估一种合成采采蝇驱避技术的有效性。我们评估了采采蝇叮咬与牛锥虫病发病率之间的关系。每个地区使用了6个村庄。每个村庄都有一群哨兵牛,每月使用血沉棕黄层技术对其进行锥虫病筛查。每次采样时发现感染的动物,按7 mg kg(-1)体重用乙酰氨基阿维菌素进行治疗。还记录了所有者在采样间隔期间进行的治疗。采样时使用诱饵固定诱捕器诱捕采采蝇,并将表观采采蝇密度估计为每个诱捕器每天捕获的采采蝇数量(FTD)。对固定比例(10%)的采采蝇进行解剖,并通过显微镜检查确定其感染状况。还从一些采采蝇中采集血餐,并使用酶联免疫吸附测定(ELISA)确定其来源。采采蝇叮咬量通过采采蝇密度、锥虫流行率以及从牛身上获取的血餐比例相乘得到。对该变量进行对数变换,并作为一个独立因素纳入泊松模型,该模型以哨兵牛的锥虫病发病率作为感兴趣的结果。恩库鲁曼和恩基尼吉地区哨兵牛群的平均锥虫病发病率分别为7.2%和10.2%。苍白采采蝇是恩库鲁曼最常见的采采蝇种类,而斯温纳顿采采蝇在恩基尼吉地区较为常见。在各自地区,有成熟感染的采采蝇比例分别为0.6%和4.2%。在恩库鲁曼采集的大多数采采蝇(28%)以疣猪为血餐来源,而在恩基尼吉采集的大多数采采蝇(30%)以牛为血餐来源。仅在恩库鲁曼地区,当汇总数据并在地区层面而非村庄层面进行分析时,采采蝇叮咬量与锥虫病发病率之间存在统计学上的显著关联。在后一种情况下,将采采蝇叮咬量滞后1个月可提高关联的强度,但不提高其显著性。这些发现表明,在观察性研究或农场试验中,当分析的空间单位较小时,例如一个村庄,可能无法证明采采蝇叮咬量与家畜锥虫病发病率之间存在统计学上的显著关联,从而无法有效控制采采蝇叮咬。