Wilson David O, Weissfeld Joel L, Fuhrman Carl R, Fisher Stephen N, Balogh Paula, Landreneau Rodney J, Luketich James D, Siegfried Jill M
Division of Pulmonary, Allergy and Critical Care Medicine, Department of Medicine, University of Pittsburgh, Pittsburgh, PA 15232, USA.
Am J Respir Crit Care Med. 2008 Nov 1;178(9):956-61. doi: 10.1164/rccm.200802-336OC. Epub 2008 Jul 17.
The role of computed tomography (CT) screening for lung cancer is controversial, currently under study, and not yet fully elucidated.
To report findings from initial and 1-year repeat screening low-radiation-dose CT of the chest and 3-year outcomes for 50- to 79-year-old current and ex-smokers in the Pittsburgh Lung Screening Study (PLuSS).
Notified of findings on screening CT, subjects received diagnostic advice from both study and personal physicians. Tracking subjects for up to three years since initial screening, we obtained medical records to document diagnostic procedures, lung cancer diagnoses, and deaths.
3,642 and 3,423 subjects had initial and repeat screening. A total of 1,477 (40.6% of 3,624) were told about noncalcified lung nodules on the initial screening and, before repeat screening, 821 (55.6% of 1,477, 22.5% of 3,642) obtained one or more subsequent diagnostic imaging studies (CT, positron emission tomography [PET], or PET-CT). Tracking identified 80 subjects with lung cancer, including 53 subjects with tumor seen at initial screening. In all, 36 subjects (1.0% of the 3,642 screened), referred for abnormalities on either the initial or repeat screening, had a major thoracic surgical procedure (thoracotomy, video-assisted thoracoscopic surgery [VATS], median sternotomy, or mediastinoscopy) leading to a noncancer final diagnosis. Out of 82 subjects with thoracotomy or VATS to exclude malignancy in a lung nodule, 28 (34.1%) received a noncancer final diagnosis. Forty of 69 (58%) subjects with non-small cell lung cancer had stage I disease at diagnosis.
Though leading to the discovery of early stage lung cancer, CT screening also led to many diagnostic follow-up procedures, including major thoracic surgical procedures with noncancer outcomes.
计算机断层扫描(CT)筛查肺癌的作用存在争议,目前仍在研究中,尚未完全阐明。
报告匹兹堡肺癌筛查研究(PLuSS)中50至79岁现吸烟者和既往吸烟者首次胸部低辐射剂量CT筛查及1年重复筛查结果,以及3年随访结果。
受试者被告知CT筛查结果后,接受来自研究医生和私人医生的诊断建议。自首次筛查起对受试者进行长达三年的跟踪,我们获取医疗记录以记录诊断程序、肺癌诊断和死亡情况。
3642名和3423名受试者分别接受了首次和重复筛查。共有1477名(3624名的40.6%)在首次筛查时被告知有非钙化肺结节,在重复筛查前,821名(1477名的55.6%,3642名的22.5%)接受了一项或多项后续诊断性影像学检查(CT、正电子发射断层扫描[PET]或PET-CT)。跟踪发现80名肺癌患者,其中53名在首次筛查时发现有肿瘤。总计36名(3642名筛查者中的1.0%)因首次或重复筛查异常而被转诊,接受了大型胸外科手术(开胸手术、电视辅助胸腔镜手术[VATS]、正中胸骨切开术或纵隔镜检查),最终诊断为非癌症。在82名接受开胸手术或VATS以排除肺结节恶性肿瘤的受试者中,28名(34.1%)最终诊断为非癌症。69名非小细胞肺癌患者中有40名(58%)在诊断时为I期疾病。
尽管CT筛查可发现早期肺癌,但也导致了许多诊断性后续程序,包括结果为非癌症的大型胸外科手术。