Pak Sang, Patten Carolynn
John Muir Rehabilitation Center, Walnut Creek, CA, USA.
Top Stroke Rehabil. 2008 May-Jun;15(3):177-99. doi: 10.1310/tsr1503-177.
Following stroke, patients/clients suffer from significant impairments. However, weakness is the predominant common denominator. Historically, strengthening or high-intensity resistance training has been excluded from neurorehabilitation programs because of the concern that high-exertion activity, including strengthening, would increase spasticity. Contemporary research studies challenge this premise.
This evidence-based review was conducted to determine whether high-intensity resistance training counteracts weakness without increasing spasticity in persons poststroke and whether resistance training is effective in improving functional outcome compared to traditional rehabilitation intervention programs. The studies selected were graded as to the strength of the recommendations and the levels of evidence. The treatment effects including control event rate (CER), experimental event rate (EER), absolute risk reduction (ARR), number needed to treat (NNT), relative benefit increase (RBI), absolute benefit increase (ABI), and relative risk (RR) were calculated when sufficient data were present.
A total of 11 studies met the criteria. The levels of evidence ranged from fair to strong (3B to 1B).
Despite limited long-term follow-up data, there is evidence that resistance training produces increased strength, gait speed, and functional outcomes and improved quality of life without exacerbation of spasticity.
中风后,患者会遭受严重的功能障碍。然而,虚弱是主要的共同特征。从历史上看,强化训练或高强度抗阻训练一直被排除在神经康复计划之外,因为担心包括强化训练在内的高强度活动会增加痉挛。当代研究对这一前提提出了挑战。
进行这项基于证据的综述,以确定高强度抗阻训练是否能在不增加中风后患者痉挛的情况下对抗虚弱,以及与传统康复干预计划相比,抗阻训练在改善功能结局方面是否有效。所选研究根据推荐强度和证据水平进行分级。当有足够数据时,计算治疗效果,包括对照事件发生率(CER)、实验事件发生率(EER)、绝对风险降低率(ARR)、治疗所需人数(NNT)、相对获益增加率(RBI)、绝对获益增加率(ABI)和相对风险(RR)。
共有11项研究符合标准。证据水平从中等到强(3B至1B)。
尽管长期随访数据有限,但有证据表明抗阻训练能增强力量、提高步速、改善功能结局并提高生活质量,且不会加重痉挛。