Barlow A D, Nakas A, Pattenden C, Martin-Ucar A E, Dennison A R, Berry D P, Lloyd D M, Robertson G S, Waller D A
Department of Thoracic Surgery, Glenfield Hospital, Leicester, UK.
Eur J Surg Oncol. 2009 Mar;35(3):307-12. doi: 10.1016/j.ejso.2008.06.012. Epub 2008 Jul 25.
Surgical resection of combined hepatic and pulmonary metastases remains controversial in light of limited supportive evidence. This study aimed to audit our initial experience with this aggressive surgical strategy.
Between 1997 and 2006 we assessed 19 patients with colorectal cancer metastases for combined liver and lung metastasectomy, of whom 16 patients underwent surgery. We retrospectively reviewed perioperative and survival data.
Synchronous liver metastases were present in three out of 16 patients at time of diagnosis of the primary tumour, and one out of 16 patients had synchronous lung and liver metastases with the primary tumour. Of those 12 patients who developed metachronous metastases five patients developed liver metastases first, one patient developed pulmonary metastases first, and six patients developed synchronous liver and lung metastases. Thirty nine operations were performed on 16 patients. The median hospital stay was 5.5 (2-10) days for the pulmonary and 7 (1-23) days for the hepatic resections. There were no in-hospital deaths. Chemotherapy was given to five patients prior to metastasectomy and nine received adjuvant chemotherapy following metastasectomy. Median survival from diagnosis of metastatic disease was 44 months (8-87 months). Estimated 1-year survival from diagnosis of metastatic disease was 94%, estimated 5-year survival was 20%.
We believe an aggressive but selective surgical approach to combined hepatic and pulmonary colorectal metastases is justified by limited resource requirements and encouraging survival.
鉴于支持性证据有限,肝肺联合转移瘤的手术切除仍存在争议。本研究旨在评估我们采用这种积极手术策略的初步经验。
1997年至2006年间,我们评估了19例结直肠癌转移患者是否适合进行肝肺联合转移瘤切除术,其中16例患者接受了手术。我们回顾性分析了围手术期和生存数据。
16例患者中,3例在原发性肿瘤诊断时存在同步肝转移,1例在原发性肿瘤诊断时存在同步肺肝转移。在那些发生异时性转移的12例患者中,5例首先发生肝转移,1例首先发生肺转移,6例发生同步肝肺转移。16例患者共进行了39次手术。肺切除术后中位住院时间为5.5(2 - 10)天,肝切除术后为7(1 - 23)天。无院内死亡病例。5例患者在转移瘤切除术前接受了化疗,9例在转移瘤切除术后接受了辅助化疗。从转移性疾病诊断后的中位生存期为44个月(8 - 87个月)。从转移性疾病诊断后的估计1年生存率为94%,估计5年生存率为20%。
我们认为,对于结直肠癌肝肺联合转移采用积极但选择性的手术方法,因其资源需求有限且生存结果令人鼓舞,是合理的。