Adhikary S, Tyagi S, Sapkota G, Afaq A, Bhattarai B K, Agrawal C S
Department of Surgery, BP Koirala Institute of Health Sciences, Dharan, Nepal.
Nepal Med Coll J. 2008 Mar;10(1):30-4.
The time honoured surgical procedure open appendectomy seems to be on the decline, it may be replaced in the modern era by laparoscopic appendectomy ("in appendectomy") performed with three trocars, or by the port exteriorization appendectomy ("out appendectomy") which can be done with two ports or even one. These techniques combine the benefits of decreased tissue trauma and operative time in addition to other advantages of minimal invasion. We conducted this study to know the effectiveness of Port Exteriorization Appendectomy, to analyze its complications and to assess the conversion rate. A one year prospective study consisted of fifty cases; a combination of emergency and elective group. They were operated under general anaesthesia and different variables were documented. Mean operative time, conversion rate, hospital stay, complications and patient satisfaction. There were 27 females with the (F: M) ratio of 1.17:1. The operative time of 23.3 mins, conversion in 4 (8.0%) patients and 2.4 days of hospital stay contributed to 86.0% operative success rate. Surgical site infection was seen in 5 (10.0%) patients and one (2.0%) developed pelvic abscess. On analysis of the satisfaction level, 44(93.6%) were completely satisfied and one (2.1%) patient seemed disappointed with the technique for cosmesis though, 42 (89.3%) remained completely satisfied and 5(10.7%) didn't like their scars. Port exteriorization appendectomy's efficacy can be verified by 86.0% success rate, operative time of 23.3 mins, indoor stay of 2.4 days, and minimal undesirable sequlae. However, more authentic results could be obtained if this technique is compared to open or laparoscopic appendectomy in a well designed randomized controlled clinical trial.
历史悠久的外科手术开放性阑尾切除术似乎正在减少,在现代可能会被使用三个套管针进行的腹腔镜阑尾切除术(“内阑尾切除术”)或可以通过两个甚至一个端口完成的端口外置阑尾切除术(“外阑尾切除术”)所取代。这些技术除了具有微创的其他优点外,还结合了减少组织创伤和手术时间的益处。我们进行这项研究以了解端口外置阑尾切除术的有效性,分析其并发症并评估转化率。一项为期一年的前瞻性研究包括五十例病例,分为急诊组和择期组。他们在全身麻醉下进行手术,并记录了不同变量,包括平均手术时间、转化率、住院时间、并发症和患者满意度。女性有27例,男女比例为1.17:1。手术时间为23.3分钟,4例(8.0%)患者需要中转手术,住院时间为2.4天,手术成功率为86.0%。5例(10.0%)患者出现手术部位感染,1例(2.0%)发生盆腔脓肿。在满意度分析中,44例(93.6%)完全满意,1例(2.1%)患者对该技术的美容效果感到失望,不过,42例(89.3%)仍完全满意,5例(10.7%)不喜欢他们的疤痕。端口外置阑尾切除术的有效性可以通过86.0%的成功率、23.3分钟的手术时间、2.4天的住院时间和极少的不良后遗症得到验证。然而,如果在精心设计的随机对照临床试验中将该技术与开放性或腹腔镜阑尾切除术进行比较,可以获得更可靠的结果。