Lian Jidong, Dundas George, Carlone Marco, Ghosh Sunita, Pearcey Robert
Department of Radiation Oncology, Cross Cancer Institute and University of Alberta, Edmonton, Canada.
Gynecol Oncol. 2008 Nov;111(2):298-306. doi: 10.1016/j.ygyno.2008.07.007. Epub 2008 Aug 23.
To evaluate clinical outcome, prognostic factors and chronic morbidity with radiotherapy for vaginal cancer treatment.
68 patients with vaginal cancer treated by radical or adjuvant radiotherapy (RT) were selected. Five with rare subtypes of histopathology and 8 with adenocarcinoma were excluded from this study. 76.4% of the remainder had early-stage diseases (stage I: 14, II: 28, III: 9, and IV: 4). The patients in the years from which they were treated were almost evenly distributed (1st 5 years: 13, 2nd: 14, 3rd: 16, and 4th: 12). There were four treatment groups: external beam radiotherapy (EBRT) alone (n=18), brachytherapy (BT) alone (n=4), EBRT and BT (n=30), and surgery plus RT (n=3).
Median follow-up was 50.3 months ranging from 3 to 213 months. 5-year overall survival (OS) was 55.6%, disease-specific survival (DSS) was 77.3%, disease-free survival was 74.2%, and local control was 87.7%. Independent prognostic factors for DSS and OS were tumor stage, site and size (p<0.05). Late radiation toxicity was minimal in the bladder (4.6%) and bowel (4.6%). Vaginal morbidity was observed in 35 patients (63.6%). It was lowest in the BT alone (0%), and highest in the EBRT and BT group (82.1%), especially for those received more than 70 Gy (p=0.05, Odds ratio=4.64, 95% confidence interval: 1.01-21.65).
This retrospective review suggested that tumor stage, site, and size were important prognostic factors in patients with vaginal cancer. Higher radiation dose was associated with more frequent vaginal toxicity.
评估放射治疗阴道癌的临床疗效、预后因素及慢性发病率。
选取68例接受根治性或辅助性放疗(RT)的阴道癌患者。本研究排除了5例组织病理学罕见亚型患者和8例腺癌患者。其余患者中76.4%为早期疾病(I期:14例,II期:28例,III期:9例,IV期:4例)。接受治疗年份的患者分布几乎均匀(第1个5年:13例,第2个5年:14例,第3个5年:16例,第4个5年:12例)。有四个治疗组:单纯外照射放疗(EBRT)(n = 18)、单纯近距离放疗(BT)(n = 4)、EBRT联合BT(n = 30)以及手术加放疗(n = 3)。
中位随访时间为50.3个月,范围为3至213个月。5年总生存率(OS)为55.6%,疾病特异性生存率(DSS)为77.3%,无病生存率为74.2%,局部控制率为87.7%。DSS和OS的独立预后因素为肿瘤分期、部位和大小(p < 0.05)。膀胱(4.6%)和肠道(4.6%)的晚期放射毒性极小。35例患者(63.6%)出现阴道并发症。单纯BT组最低(0%),EBRT联合BT组最高(82.1%),尤其是接受超过70 Gy照射的患者(p = 0.05,比值比 = 4.64,95%置信区间:1.01 - 21.65)。
这项回顾性研究表明,肿瘤分期、部位和大小是阴道癌患者重要的预后因素。较高的放射剂量与更频繁的阴道毒性相关。