Diehm Nicolas, Katzen Barry T, Samuels Shaun, Pena Constantino, Powell Alex, Dick Florian
Baptist Cardiac and Vascular Institute, Miami, Florida, USA.
J Vasc Interv Radiol. 2008 Sep;19(9):1283-8. doi: 10.1016/j.jvir.2008.04.013. Epub 2008 Jun 3.
To quantify the interobserver variability of abdominal aortic aneurysm (AAA) neck length and angulation measurements.
A total of 25 consecutive patients scheduled for endovascular AAA repair underwent follow-up 64-row computed tomographic (CT) angiography in 0.625-mm collimation. AAA neck length and angulation were determined by four blinded, independent readers. AAA neck length was defined as the longitudinal distance between the first transverse CT slice directly distal to the lowermost renal artery and the first transverse CT slice that showed at least a 15% larger outer aortic wall diameter versus the diameter measured directly below the lowermost renal artery. Infrarenal AAA neck angulation was defined as the true angle between the longitudinal axis of the proximal AAA neck and the longitudinal axis of the AAA lumen as analyzed on three-dimensional CT reconstructions.
Mean deviation in aortic neck length determination was 32.3% and that in aortic neck angulation was 32.1%. Interobserver variability of aortic neck length and angulation measurements was considerable: in any reader combination, at least one measurement difference was outside the predefined limits of agreement.
Assessment of the longitudinal extension and angulation of the infrarenal aortic neck is associated with substantial observer variability, even if measurement is carried out according to a standardized protocol. Further studies are mandatory to assess dedicated technical approaches to minimize variance in the determination of the longitudinal extension and angulation of the infrarenal aortic neck.
量化腹主动脉瘤(AAA)颈部长度和角度测量的观察者间变异性。
共有25例计划接受AAA血管内修复术的连续患者接受了准直为0.625mm的64排计算机断层扫描(CT)血管造影随访。AAA颈部长度和角度由四名不知情的独立读者确定。AAA颈部长度定义为紧邻最下方肾动脉的第一个横向CT切片与显示主动脉外壁直径比在最下方肾动脉正下方测量值至少大15%的第一个横向CT切片之间的纵向距离。肾下AAA颈部角度定义为在三维CT重建上分析的近端AAA颈部纵轴与AAA管腔纵轴之间的真实角度。
主动脉颈部长度测定的平均偏差为32.3%,主动脉颈部角度测定的平均偏差为32.1%。主动脉颈部长度和角度测量的观察者间变异性相当大:在任何读者组合中,至少有一个测量差异超出了预先定义的一致性限度。
即使按照标准化方案进行测量,肾下主动脉颈部纵向延伸和角度的评估仍存在显著的观察者变异性。必须进行进一步研究以评估专门的技术方法,以尽量减少肾下主动脉颈部纵向延伸和角度测定中的差异。