Mancuso J E, Abramow S P, Dimichino B R, Landsman M J
Department of Podiatric Surgery, Medical Arts Center Hospital, New York, New York.
J Foot Surg. 1991 May-Jun;30(3):238-43.
Patients receiving treatment for plantar verruca by carbon dioxide laser vaporization from 1984 through 1989 were surveyed with follow-up from 3 months to 6 years. Materials and methods, operative technique, and results were reviewed. This procedure was used as both a primary treatment as well as secondary or tertiary treatments on recalcitrant verrucae. Solitary as well as multiple or mosaic lesions were evaluated. Patients were surveyed for elimination of all verrucae, partial or complete recurrence, postoperative complications, and satisfaction. The overall success rate, considering all eight treatment categories, was 75%. Ultimate success rates ranged from 93% for solitary lesions to 62% for multiple recalcitrant lesions. The authors' findings show clinical significance in the marked differentiation of success rates in accordance with the classification scheme. That is to say, initial treatment of a solitary lesion showed a higher success rate than initial treatment of multiple lesions, and initial treatment of virgin lesions showed a higher success rate than initial treatment of recalcitrant lesions. Based on the data accumulated, the authors propose that treatment of plantar verruca be initiated early, i.e., while the lesion is solitary and has been heretofore untreated. On the other hand, those lesions having a second or third treatment by carbon dioxide laser vaporization resulted in a higher ultimate success rate than those which had only one primary treatment. The general conclusion is that carbon dioxide laser management should be considered as a viable treatment alternative in relation to other, more traditional, techniques in the treatment of plantar verruca.
对1984年至1989年期间接受二氧化碳激光汽化治疗足底疣的患者进行了调查,随访时间为3个月至6年。回顾了材料与方法、手术技术及结果。该方法既用于初治,也用于对顽固性疣的二次或三次治疗。对单发以及多发或镶嵌状损害均进行了评估。对患者进行了如下调查:所有疣体是否消除、部分或完全复发、术后并发症及满意度。考虑所有八个治疗类别,总体成功率为75%。最终成功率范围为:单发损害为93%,多发顽固性损害为62%。作者的研究结果表明,根据分类方案,成功率的显著差异具有临床意义。也就是说,单发损害的初始治疗成功率高于多发损害的初始治疗,初发损害的初始治疗成功率高于顽固性损害的初始治疗。基于积累的数据,作者建议足底疣的治疗应尽早开始,即当损害为单发且此前未治疗时。另一方面,那些接受二氧化碳激光汽化二次或三次治疗的损害,其最终成功率高于仅接受一次初治的损害。总的结论是,与其他更传统的技术相比,二氧化碳激光治疗应被视为治疗足底疣的一种可行替代方法。